Great book

I am a therapist who treats many clients with PTSD. I found this book to be amazingly insightful and informative. Highly recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The hell where youth and laugher go

As I was driving into work one day on the 5 South, passing the University of California at Irvine that David J. Morris mentions several times in "The Evil Hours: A Biography of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder" (2015), I heard something in the narration that truly shocked me. Sharp intake of breath, cold running from my hands to my feet, pounding pulse surprise. Morris mentions that some people actually ask veterans if they've killed.

I served on active duty in the US Army from 1982 to 1986, and I'm not one of the few people that saw combat in Granada. My drill instructors were in Vietnam, though, and so were a lot of my senior commanders. Asking that question was the strongest taboo I ever encountered in military life. It simply wasn't done. As soldiers, we collectively understood that trauma belonged to the soldier, to be shared by choice. And if a soldier chose to share, you listened attentively, you learned, and you were grateful.

Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) isn't a new condition, although the term is. Morris traces its scientific, ethical and sociological development - its genealogy, as he calls it. His emphasis is on Western conflicts, especially the American Civil War and World War I, and of course, Vietnam. Morris delves deeply into the moral conflicts that can cause or contribute to PTSD, even after a 'good war' like World War II.

Morris' discussion of treatments for the disorder is both fascinating and horrifying. He has PTSD and has treated for it through the Veterans Administration hospitals. One widely accepted treatment, Prolonged Exposure (PE) left him so debilitated he stopped treatment - but only after breaking a knife blade stabbing his cell phone. Cognitive processing therapy (CPT) did help him - and it certainly sounds like most people respond better to that. Medications like Paxil work for some people, but no one is sure why. Morris explores alternative treatments, and it sounds like one in particular works well for a lot of folks: yoga.

Morris doesn't limit his discussion of PTSD to combat veterans. Rape is one cause of trauma he discusses extensively, as well as the difference in PTSD signs, symptoms and treatment between men and women.

"The Evil Hours" is wide ranging and sometimes difficult to follow. Morris jumps from philosophy, history, neurobiology and neuroscience, pharmacology, cultural conditions, technological developments in armaments . . .

It's a difficult listen. It's intellectually challenging, and compelling. I would have done better with it on text, but I wouldn't have been able to sit down and read it for months, or maybe even years. I found myself wanting to tell Morris to slow down and explore his ideas in more depth, but I realized that he's set down a guide for what could be his life's work, and will guide researchers interested in PTSD for years.

This is another Audible I wish had a true Table of Contents, so here it is (with thanks to Villanova's on line library) Audible 1 - Introduction; Audible 2 - The warning; Audible 3 - Saydia; Audible 4 - In terror's shadow; Audible 5 - Toward a genealogy of trauma; Audible 6 - The haunted mind; Audible 7 - Modern trauma; Audible 8 - Therapy; Audible 9 - Drugs; Audible 10 - Alternatives; Audible 11 - Growth; Audible 12 -Counterfactuals; and Audible 13 - Epilogue.

I wasn't that wild about the book as an Audible, and it could have used an edit. It tended to meander and get repetitive. I am giving it 5's because the importance of the work makes up for an occasional lack of focus or an obscure point. Giving it any less would make me feel like I'm devaluing a landmark.

The title of the review is from Siegfried Sassoon's "The War Poems."

[If this review helped, please press YES. Thanks!]

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

20 people found this helpful

perspective-changing

narrator was great. made me feel like I was sitting in a bar with him or his den or our therapy group. material and content was raw & descriptive. i hope I never forget this book & the horrors of war.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

TRAUMA

In most lives, there is at least one trauma; i.e. a traumatic experience that imprints a sense of unease, fear, or terror that affirms physical mortality. It may be a near death experience, a car crash, a sexual assault, a natural disaster, or the relentless physical/mental trauma of war.

David Morris is a former marine who served his country in the 1990s, when America is between wars. After four years, Morris resigns his commission and returns to civilian life. Then, 9/11 occurs. America becomes embroiled in Iraq and Morris chooses to become an embedded civilian reporter. That fateful decision leads Morris to a mental dysfunction widely known as Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.

In the end, Morris suggests PTSD is fundamentally a symptom of time distortion. There is no universal cure but his journey infers that any treatment that makes the sufferer “live-in-the-moment” rather than the past will ameliorate PTSD’s debilitating consequences. Contrary to the desire of the Veterans Administration, Morris infers science will not discover any universal therapy that effectively treats PTSD. Causes are too diverse. However, Morris suggests PTSD has a redeeming quality for some that survive its debilitating symptoms. PTSD’ survival can change the course of one’s life for the better with recognition of humanity’s interconnection and the value of living life well.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Remarkable

Truly remarkable from beginning to end... The author does an exceptional job of mixing his personal story with the history of PTSD and where things currently stand today. As someone with family in the military and also as someone who has found a calling in working in the world of mental health...this book is truly incredible. It's real...very very real.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good coverage of military PTSD

In this important work, Morris traces the history of what we now call post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), even back into the ancient days. He begins the book with his own experiences with PTSD. He then talks about how PTSD affects the lives of its sufferers. He also discusses the major treatments for PTSD, many of which he has tried out himself. He apparently interviewed quite a few people for the book - at least he claims he did - though those interviews are generally chiseled down into two or three sentence mentions.


One thing that disappointed me is that this is not a book about PTSD in general - it is a book about PTSD in military. PTSD is suffered more by women than by men. Most Americans with PTSD are women who have been raped or beaten or otherwise traumatized during a non-war setting. One review I read said "rape is also discussed extensively." It wasn't. Rape got a side comment every once in a while - generally in the form of a quote from Alice Sebold's memoir. However, most of the research on PTSD, and Morris' own personal experience with PTSD, is military-related, therefore it is understandable that he would focus on military PTSD. Plus, if you actually read the jacket carefully (which I did not), it's pretty clear that this is a book mostly about military PTSD.

The book also tended to wander and get a bit dull at times, but its important content made up for this minor annoyance. In the end, I thought this was a good book that could have been an amazing book if he had taken that extra step to include womens' experiences a little more.

The narrator was great - no complaints there.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Very powerful, engaging, and educational

This was a powerful book. The personal stories woven amidst the history/“biography” of PTSD was an extremely engaging way to tell both these stories simultaneously. Highly recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Absolutely incredible

Deeply personal stories wrapped up in a fascinating timeline and summary of PTSD. Fascinating, well-researched, well-written, well-performed.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent!

Thought provoking and thoughtfully written. I hope this will not be the last work for David J Morris.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Exceptional, educational and touching

This was more than what I imagined I was getting when I selected this book. I heard David Morris interviewed in NPR. He unselfishly reveals his own struggle, and at the same time has created a very comprehensive, well researched history of PTSD. Just as valuable was his approach to submitting some very thought provoking questions about war decisions and the field of psychology and psychiatric treatment past and present. I grew by listening to this book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!