If by “exciting “ you mean slow, dry and lacking focus ..

I agree. Yet using a more widely accepted definition of the word, this writing falls considerably short of the standard. I concede the performance may have been possible to pull the heavy, disjointed story together, but that is a heavy lift for any actor being challenged by a character termed “ a small man in a big body “. I didn’t immediately piece together the implications of this way of being for the feature protagonist, but it was revealed clearly and repeatedly once I began looking for the small minded simpleton characteristics after that first tip off.
Frankly I love a police procedural firing on all cylinders to solve crime. This version features the romance aspect at the forefront which may appeal to other listeners but it’s not for me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

An intriguing tale

First question - why can't we see all the reviewer ratings like we used to? According to the page this recording is on there are between 5 and 8 reviews, yet I cannot see all of them. Why not an option on the drop down menu for "all" versus the options there now which I could care less about. I am writing this review because of the 1 negative and 1 positive we are allowed to see and feel that this book is well worth a listen. I really enjoyed the story and the narrator. The main character is described as a shy, uncommunicative type of guy and I think the reader really captured that. This protagonist is more of a real person versus the tough guy cops often depicted. The only character I felt was underdeveloped was his wife, who, although described as wonderful, is portrayed only as a sex object. She herself, in late term pregnancy, is also quite the minx. I doubt that a female writer would have created this character, but since she is not key to the story line, this weakness (clearly my view only) did not effect my overall appreciation of the book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

"The quality of mercy...."

There's a new cop in the English city of Hull. No sooner does he start his job than he views a 15 year old Somalian adopted girl being slash down in their central church. He has even seen the hooded slasher. But is he a serial killer? Seems that survivors of fatal incidents are being murdered. Thus starts this gruesome murder mystery with a unique plot for a murderer.

Perhaps some of the best parts are the development of the characters. Aector McAvoy is definitely an experienced cop, and rumors abound about his past with a dirty cop and a paid killer. Now he's supposed to be relegated to computer work because of his unique talents in finding information from a desk. His female supervisor tries to untangle his skills through his quiet personality. Aector is profoundly in love with his beautiful wife and young son. Through all this is the description of a dank and wet city of Hull.

This was a great start for a continuing mystery series. Aector is not reminiscent of any policeman that I've previously read about. I also appreciated the twisted motive that was also unique to this story. Definitely will read more from this author. Listened to this on Audible and really appreciated the dramatic affect, especially Aector's Scottish accent amongst the English.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A very good twisty plot with great reading.

Mysteries have been my choice for reading (now listening) matter with biographies a runner up for 40 years. I enjoy that British and European stories have more twists and turns than many I have read by American authors which are either too cute by half or thrillers and shockers better suited to television and movies to make you jump out of your seat. It doesn’t matter that the author gave enough clues for me to figure out the killer a few chapters before the reveal. I portioned out Ian Rankin’s to make them last so am very happy to find a new series with attributes I like. Also pleased there are accents by good actors which helps to individualize the characters.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Great new entry into British mysteries

I love mysteries, especially those set in the British Isles. This book is a bit slow in parts (I didn't care for all of the scenes of domestic bliss) and I would I have like the minor characters to be more fleshed out. However, the story is gripping (once you make it past the introductory chapters.) I will definitely "read" the other entries in this series.

John Curless gives a great performance, making the characters distinct and voicing the women as well as the men.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

This guy is great.

At last, another reliable mystery author! Modest Scottish detective solves crimes in Hull. He loves his wife. He is rightly suspicious of his collegues. Lots of atmosphere.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

My opinion

A decent story but way way too many f words. It was very distracting. I don’t know why they have to be used

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Wish I'd Saved The Credit

I was looking forward to the beginning of a new series with a great new character to follow This ain't it. The main character, DS McAvoy, is nothing but a politically correct wuss who is supposedly crazy in love with his wife, but lusts after his female boss. Huh??? I've never read a book who's main character has less personality than McAvoy. And as a previous reviewer commented, the story could indeed do with a bit less domestic bliss. It added little to the plot and made me question just how much McAvoy loves his wife if he's conflicted about wether or not to kiss his overtly sexual boss.

I did a quick google search and found that the population of Scotland is over 5 1/4 million people. That said, could they not have found a narrator who can convincingly voice a Scottish character? Why do audiobook publisher's not check first to see if the chosen narrator can actually deliver a convincing accent? Why is it so hard to find narrators who can "speak Scots"? I've lost count of the times I have been disappointed in a narrator because of this. It really ruins the listening experience. Mr. Curless may be quite good at various English dialects, but he is AWFUL with the Scots accent. It was so bad that I couldn't wait for this book to end. This, coupled with the fact that his voice is SO gravelly, grated on my nerves so badly that I ended up listening on 3X speed just to get this book finished.

My advice is to save your credit. I won't be listening to anything else by this author or narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful

Ok but not great...

The plot itself was pretty good with a serial killer targeting people who had survived precious horrors - but the writing was hard to wade through at times. The author chose to write in the present tense which I found irritating and pointless- it didn’t help the story and struck me as rather pretentious. The main character was portrayed in ways that made him seem stupid at times like a big lumbering oaf - more of a caricature than a real person. The attempt to create some sexual tension between the hero and his boss was kind of creepy and sleezy. I’m not going to read any more of this series because the author just didn’t do a very good job of telling the story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

EXCRUCIATING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What disappointed you about The Dark Winter?

The protagonist, Detective Sergeant Aector McAvoy is such a craven, irredeemably moronic figure that one cannot even appreciate the genuinely intriguing elements of the mystery as they come together. And due to the fact that it is he who interacts with some genuinely interesting characters throughout the narrative, one cannot help but long for a different story, involving the latter, but absolutely lacking DS McAvoy.

Did John Curless do a good job differentiating all the characters? How?

Curless is exceptional; unfortunately, since he spends most of the story narrating from McAvoy's perspective, one must listen to the pusillanimous, weepy, submissive voice he uses for McAvoy for most of the audiobook.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!