If the away defeat to Cardiff exposed the most challenging aspects of the previous head coach’s approach, the 1-1 home draw in the six-pointer against a dogged Cardiff perhaps did the same for Miron Muslic.

A Pilgrims Podcast full house gathers to review an underwhelming home performance. There is some debate on the how and the why – not enough football played, too much football attempted? – but the chance to draw clear of the relegation places, at least for one day, was just taken. The limitations of the coach, team, and system are all reviewed as, through gritted teeth, perhaps (a big perhaps) this may prove to be a vital point.

In Part 2, the rest of the season comes into focus—firstly in general terms and then with a spotlight on the upcoming fifth-round cup tie in Manchester. Is the cup a huge opportunity, a distraction, or is it both? There is then discussion of a reassuring fans' forum and a reminder that, off the pitch at least, things seem stable once more and heading in the right direction—even if, in the short term, that will most likely be in as few passes as possible.

Finally, look out in the week for some stellar guests in upcoming Cup Specials.

You can stick your blue moon… sideways. COYG.

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

A game and a result that was always likely to divide opinions – an agricultural slogfest or a retro work of art? BBC Radio Devon commentator Michael McCann shares his post-match thoughts, while friend of the pod Michael Savage gives us a first-hand account of his night in that iconic away end.

The Battle of Kenilworth Road and what could be a huge point as the season develops is the focus. Under the cosh from minute one, there is consensus that there is a plan, even if that plan is sometimes not easy on the eye. The injustice of a disallowed goal, whether there’s always someone to blame for conceding, and the early signs of a set-piece coach in action are all under the microscope. Even the referee felt like he was from a bygone era in a stadium from another time.

From a game that felt like the past to a focus on the future. Can a siege mentality be sustained in the face of a heavy fixture load? Should we be worried about a lack of goal threat or elated about the goals scored? Or isn’t it just great to still be in the mix?

Quick thoughts on the upcoming fans' forum close things out.

Bring on Cardiff.

Support the show

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

In this episode, the hosts are joined by One Team in Devon to discuss a return to planet away day at Blackburn. Friend of the pod and BBC Radio Devon commentator, Drew Savage, sends in a voice note sharing his views from the commentary box, offering his perspective on the game.

The key focus is the impact of Ryan Hardie’s injury, the team’s performance (we’ve played better, but certainly worse too), and what this means in the run-up to a season-defining run of fixtures.

They review a strong performance by a high-flying Rovers side, the pros and cons of rotation, the significance of the upcoming matches, and the overall dynamics of the team as they navigate a challenging season.

Inevitably, the future of a frontline that was looking so positive is under detailed review. Can Baidoo show more signs of promise? Why do other forwards struggle so much with the Muslic method? Should the free market be explored, or are there better options closer to home?

Finally, thoughts turn to the mother of all six-pointers at Luton and a run of games against relegation rivals—only interrupted by a certain Mr Guardiola.

Never dull. COYG.

Support the show: https://ko-fi.com/pilgrimspodcast

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Archie, Alex, and Chris return for yet more delirium as they break down Plymouth Argyle’s stunning 5-1 win over Millwall. The trio tries to make sense of these dizzying heights, dissecting a game that carried so much pressure—yet was nearly over after just 10 minutes. Praise is heaped on the golden front three of Wright, Bundu, and Hardie, as well as Muslic’s eye for talent and ability to mould players into new roles.

They dive into Muslic’s coaching philosophy, player development, and the growing chemistry within the squad, emphasising the intensity and teamwork driving Argyle’s recent success. There’s also a deep appreciation for the squad’s resilience and spirit, as they reflect on how far the club has come despite the challenges.

In Part 2, attention turns to the 5th round glamour tie against Manchester City—as the pod sits back in disbelief and dares to dream of another upset. With a few days to process the Liverpool euphoria, they reflect on the international coverage the result has received and take a more rational perspective on the win. Elsewhere, they discuss the appointment of set-piece coach Hubert Auer and the huge task he has ahead.

Finally, Part 3 wraps up with a look ahead to Blackburn away—before a chaotic quiz brings things to a close.

Support the show: https://ko-fi.com/pilgrimspodcast

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Plymouth Argyle 1 - 0 Liverpool.

PLYMOUTH ARGYLE 1 - 0 LIVERPOOL!

In a mammoth, giddy two-hour plus episode, Archie, Tom, Mark, and Chris unpack what is, quite possibly, the greatest result in Argyle’s history. As the pod slowly comes to its senses, they relive the many unforgettable moments from the match—Katic’s 101 clearances, Hazard’s heroics, yet more Maxi fist-bumping mayhem, Ryan’s beautiful cup redemption, Sorinola pocketing Díaz, and so much more. Moments that will forever be etched in Argyle folklore.

Naturally, attention turns to Muslic—his tactical masterclass and his perfect balance of calmness and belief, both before and after the game.

As the dust settles, the pod looks ahead to a monumental run of eight games before the next international break, starting with Millwall at home. While a six-pointer-packed schedule looms large in Argyle’s fight for survival, there’s a newfound sense of optimism—are we finally starting to believe?

There are also well-deserved mentions for the women’s and youth teams, plus a quick reflection on a mixed-bag transfer deadline day.

In part three, the pod discusses dream draws for the fifth round before rounding off this gargantuan episode with a quiz.

Support the show: https://ko-fi.com/pilgrimspodcast

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

In this episode of the Pilgrims Podcast, the hosts break down a much-needed victory, analysing the debut of new centre-backs, the game plan, and a controversial penalty that proved to be a turning point. Ryan Hardie takes centre stage as they assess his impact—not just as a substitute in the match, but across his five-year spell at Argyle.

Part Two shifts focus to transfer activity, player performances, and the race against the clock as the deadline looms. Morgan Whittaker’s departure remains a key talking point, alongside the urgent need for smart recruitment and a possible replacement. The conversation also touches on the goalkeeper situation, with rumours of a Grimshaw exit. There’s also time to discuss Joe Edwards’ appearances on Sky, Schumacher at Bolton, and, most importantly, Nance receiving his richly deserved “Freedom of the City.”

Finally, attention turns to the road ahead, with growing optimism (or is it false hope?) surrounding Argyle’s relegation fight. With crucial battles against relegation rivals on the horizon—and a surreal FA Cup tie against Liverpool thrown into the mix—how do Argyle balance survival and spectacle? There’s even time for a rare quiz, much to Mark’s delight, with the squad’s diverse international make-up as the topic of the day.

Emirates FA Cup Live Tour with Dion Dublin: https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/emirates-fa-cup-live-tour-with-dion-dublin-plymouth-tickets-1214814395559?aff=oddtdtcreator

Support the show: https://ko-fi.com/pilgrimspodcast

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

In this episode of the Pilgrims Podcast, hosts Archie, Tom, Chris, and special guest Drew Savage start with a discussion of a much-improved performance at Sunderland. They analyse the line-up changes, half-time insights, and the impact (and absence) of key players. There is cautious optimism about the team's potential—even if it still does seem too late—and Tom forgets to use the phrase Ogbgasm to describe a thrilling finish.

Part Two inevitably dives into a deeply challenging week, drawing on the leadership style of Miron Muslic and the implications of player mentality on team performance, especially following the car crash that was Burnley. Morgan someone also gets a mention, as does the club’s increased commitment to communications in difficult times. They explore the difficulties in selling players at their peak, the need for strategic foresight in recruitment, and the urgency and difficulty of filling gaps during a busy January.

Finally, thoughts turn to potential incomings, the relative luxury of a week’s time on the grass for the new Head Coach, and another must-win—or must-perform?—against West Brom.

Keep it Green.

Any contribution towards running costs is always welcome:

https://ko-fi.com/pilgrimspodcast

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

In this episode of the Archie, Chris, Mark and Tom wallow in the aftermath of a(nother) disappointing defeat.

In focus in part one are the team's performance, tactical decisions, and managerial challenges both in the moment and over the course of a long and difficult it period for the club. Players' capabilities, the impact of injuries, and increasing relegation concerns are common and challenging themes.

The conversation further examines the need for better recruitment and the potential for future success, while also addressing the emotional toll on fans and the team. Fan and player fatigue, managerial changes, and recruitment strategies all feature as challenging

Thoughts finally turn to the upcoming January transfer window and the need for effective recruitment to bolster the squad. As they look ahead to future matches, the hosts express a mix of hope and concern about the team's prospects.

Any contribution towards running costs is always welcome:

https://ko-fi.com/pilgrimspodcast

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.