A truly unique tale

Such a strange and enthralling story, I really couldn't predict where it would go next! There are some story beats that don't quite sit right with me, but overall I'm happier having read this book than not. If you're looking for a truly alien sci-fi experience, this book is for you.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Tell Don’t Show

Really interesting premise. Could have been so much richer world building. But all the characters seem the same and don’t have unique personalities. And there is SO much telling. “Then we talked” and another crisis is averted. It gets frustrating to not see how things change, only getting told they suddenly got better. I’m surprised this is a final draft of anything. Hard to follow. Skips around way too much. So much of it just seems like youthful drama than an actual lived in world.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Some Intriguing Ideas

There are some very interesting ideas in this story, however, the book never captured my interest.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Loved it! so goey and interesting

I really loved this one. I was pretty skeptical, but turns out I’m all here for goey living ships, and I was a huge fan of the interesting and very queer society. It has some flaws, especially in the plot department, but I actually liked some aspects that I saw others were not keen on.

Escaping Exodus by Nicky Drayden is sci fi story taking place on a living spaceship. A huge, goey, often disgusting, beast flying through space with humans modifying it so they can live inside. A lot of the focus is on the ship itself, all the challenges it poses, and on the society that inhabits it.

I loved the spaceship beast. It was so unusual and on such a massive scale. Imagine having arteries so wide that people can walk through them to do maintenance work. Gut bacteria so big they pose a real danger to humans, as if they were wild animals. Drayden does a very good job of making this very alien environment feel real. It’s very visceral, and especially towards the end, not for the squeamish. This is a bit hard to explain without spoilers, but I don’t normally like the sort of thing that happened, but the MC having a very positive outlook on the whole thing really made it easier to get through.

The society is very interesting, it’s very matriarchal, and I particularly liked how the family unit evolved to fit the constrained nature of spaceship life. There are two point of view characters, one giving us a picture of the most privileged layer of society and the other of the working class and a peek at the lowest. The book is generally highly critical of humans, especially how we impact the environment and treat the less privileged. I liked how the way men’s choices were limited in the matriarchal society points out how absurd things like that are in any society. I think that the way that the higher ups relate to the people with the lowest standing in society could’ve been elaborated on more, it just felt too brutal to not come with more of an explanation as to how that came to be.

The story itself is somewhat familiar, young people growing up and facing disillusionment about the world around them, dealing with injustice and trying to fix the world as they get to know it. We follow two characters Seske, daughter of the matriarch, destined to rule her entire people, and Adala, her childhood friend and love interest, a talented heart worker, her working class origins make her an impossible match for the future Matris. I really liked how perfectly queer it is, having both male and female love interests is the norm.

Seske’s challenges are about dealing with what is expected of her, mixed with grim realizations about the truth of life on the space beast and her perpetually souring relationship with her sister. Adala faces challenges of her own, also with both her role in society and the way it operates.

This is where the general complaint comes in. There are many story threads, with Seske’s and Adala’s relationship, their families, all sorts of smaller and bigger emergencies on the ship, shifts in society. Some of them feel pretty rushed. Often it is done in a way I actually liked, there’d be a problem and then characters would figure out how to solve it and it’s sort of solved off screen and the story skips ahead. I liked how that avoided wasting time on something that would be sorted out anyway.

I listened to the audiobook I think that really brought the text to life. Between the different kinds of vernacular used and the narrator’s performance the different groups and classes really felt very distinct.

This is one of those books that’s pretty unique in what it does and how it does it, so it’s hard to say “I recommend this to fans of X” when I haven’t read anything quite like it. Just, give it a shot if living ships and interesting societies tickle your fancy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

10/10 Sci-fi!

Drayden is the future of the genre. This was next level weird and cool AF.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Pure Chaos--in a good way.

This has been the first book in years that had me hooked nearly immediately. I kept needing to find a chance to keep listening and I found myself thinking about it often.

The story was intense, barrier-breaking, and emotional. The characters are very inclusive. The descriptions are so well done that you can almost see what they see, taste what they taste, smell what they smell.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Tells instead of shows; second reader is unbearable

Someone else wrote a review saying this book does too much telling not enough showing. I completely agree. It’s a fascinating premise and there’s enough exploration of the world the author is constructing to make me interested in its details, but the plot is really all over the place. It feels like anything can happen at any time and the characters don’t seem like they are inhabiting a really lived in world with it’s own rules and realties. I was interested in Seske’s parts more because she has a couple interesting secondary characters around her but Adala’s story is really really unpredictable and all over the place. First she’s a prodigy then she’s a drug addict and she finds a secret sister then she’s fired and her secret sister is gone and her stoic mildly abusive mom is responsible but then her stoic mildly abusive mom is sad about it. Also the reader for Adala uses the same cloying reverent wistful affect for literally. Every. Sentence. And it gets unbearable very quickly. I wish this book was written differently but as it is I couldn’t get through more than 50%.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

World building is a mess and confusing. Too hard.

Some of the worst world building I've experienced. So many info dumps, constant flow of details that are not written well enough to picture what is going on. This was soooo difficult to figure out what in the world was going on that it became more frustrating the longer I went on.

I DNF'd at 30%, it just kept getting worse and worse.

The characters just are a confusing mess too quickly at the beginning too. Who is who and why should I care about them? Ugh. I hated this

Maybe I'll give it a try another day but there's too many good books in the world to bother with something this difficult to read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!