Carnage
Four Horsemen, Book 1
Failed to add items
Add to Cart failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Get 2 free audiobooks during trial.
Buy for $19.95
No default payment method selected.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
-
Narrated by:
-
Zara Hampton Brown
-
David William Keegan
-
By:
-
Sarah Bailey
About this listen
Prescott Ellis - Pestilence They call us The Four Horsemen. Four friends forged in fire and blood. No one knows where we came from nor how we got our name. Drake, Francis, West and I rule the financial industry like kings. Gods in our own right. We grew up with a fifth. A girl. Scarlett. She was one of us until she was ripped away from her life. The only trace of her was dust in the wind. One day she returned to the city and sought us out.
Scarlett couldn’t remember who we’d been to her, but we recalled her all too well. If she knew what was good for her, she would have never come back. The moment she stepped through the doors of Fortuity, it was the beginning of her end. And the start of our reign over the girl who wanted us dead. A dark why choose contemporary retelling of the four horsemen of the apocalypse set in Sarah Bailey's Dark Universe with cliffhangers and a HEA in the final book. This is a DARK romance and therefore comes with a content warning. Please see the author's website for full details. Duet Narration by Zara Hampton Brown and David William Keegan.
©2021 Sarah Bailey (P)2022 Sarah BaileyListeners also enjoyed...
-
The Ritual
- By: Shantel Tessier
- Narrated by: Aiden Snow, Meg Sylvan
- Length: 16 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Barrington University is home of the Lords, a secret society that requires their blood in payment. They are above all—the most powerful men in the world. They devote their lives to violence in exchange for power. And during their senior year, they are offered a chosen one.
-
-
Waste of a credit!!
- By delsea on 05-18-23
By: Shantel Tessier
-
Losers: Part 1
- By: Harley LaRoux
- Narrated by: Jaclyn Kelso, J. Tipstone
- Length: 16 hrs and 1 min
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I’d been prom queen and cheer captain—high school’s most savage Queen Bee. I could have everything I wanted. Except them. The freaks, the weirdos, the school’s ultimate losers: Manson, Jason, Lucas, and Vincent. Our hatred for each other couldn’t keep us apart, not even when my own mistake got Manson expelled and made me the ultimate villain to the rest of them.
-
-
All the stars! Credit WORTHY!
- By Sarah on 08-12-23
By: Harley LaRoux
-
Does It Hurt?
- By: H. D. Carlton
- Narrated by: Troy Duran, Michelle Sparks
- Length: 12 hrs and 7 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Who am I? I've forgotten the answer to that question long ago. Ever since I ran from that house, so desperate to escape, I left with only the clothes on my back and socks on my feet. After that day, I've only ever walked in stolen shoes.
-
-
This is a tough one
- By Julie Price on 05-01-23
By: H. D. Carlton
-
Filthy Wicked Psychos: Complete Series
- By: Eva Ashwood
- Narrated by: Cassandra Medcalf, Daniel James Lewis
- Length: 52 hrs and 49 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was the girl no one looked at twice. Until they saw me. My whole life, no one has had my back. My parents are dead, my adoptive mother is a drug addict, and the mean girls on campus mock me for my scars. So when I end up desperate for money and out of options, I agree to sell the one thing I have left: my innocence. On the night I’m meant to give my body to a brutal Russian mobster, three men storm into the room like dark shadows and kill him before he can claim me. When they drag me from the blood-soaked bed, I’m certain they’re going to kill me too.
-
-
steamy but repetitive
- By Kacee on 11-20-24
By: Eva Ashwood
-
Butcher & Blackbird
- The Ruinous Love Trilogy, Book 1
- By: Brynne Weaver
- Narrated by: Joe Arden, Lucy Rivers
- Length: 8 hrs and 43 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When a chance encounter sparks an unlikely bond between rival murderers Sloane and Rowan, the two find something elusive—the friendship of a like-minded, pitch-black soul. From small-town West Virginia to upscale California, from downtown Boston to rural Texas, the two hunters collide in an annual game of blood and suffering, one that pits them against the most dangerous monsters in the country.
-
-
Listen, I'm a 'sympathetic retcher'
- By J. Scarlyn on 10-25-23
By: Brynne Weaver
-
Den of Vipers
- By: K.A. Knight
- Narrated by: Cornell Collins, Hollie Jackson
- Length: 19 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Ryder, Garrett, Kenzo, and Diesel - The Vipers. Their deals are as sordid as their business, and their reputation is enough to bring a grown man to his knees, forcing him to beg for mercy. They are not people you mess with, yet my dad did. The old man ran up a debt with them and then sold me to cover his losses. Yes, sold me. They own me now. I’m theirs in every sense of the word. But I’ve never been meek and compliant.
-
-
Shrek
- By Shemika Holmes on 02-25-21
By: K.A. Knight
-
The Ritual
- By: Shantel Tessier
- Narrated by: Aiden Snow, Meg Sylvan
- Length: 16 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Barrington University is home of the Lords, a secret society that requires their blood in payment. They are above all—the most powerful men in the world. They devote their lives to violence in exchange for power. And during their senior year, they are offered a chosen one.
-
-
Waste of a credit!!
- By delsea on 05-18-23
By: Shantel Tessier
-
Losers: Part 1
- By: Harley LaRoux
- Narrated by: Jaclyn Kelso, J. Tipstone
- Length: 16 hrs and 1 min
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I’d been prom queen and cheer captain—high school’s most savage Queen Bee. I could have everything I wanted. Except them. The freaks, the weirdos, the school’s ultimate losers: Manson, Jason, Lucas, and Vincent. Our hatred for each other couldn’t keep us apart, not even when my own mistake got Manson expelled and made me the ultimate villain to the rest of them.
-
-
All the stars! Credit WORTHY!
- By Sarah on 08-12-23
By: Harley LaRoux
-
Does It Hurt?
- By: H. D. Carlton
- Narrated by: Troy Duran, Michelle Sparks
- Length: 12 hrs and 7 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Who am I? I've forgotten the answer to that question long ago. Ever since I ran from that house, so desperate to escape, I left with only the clothes on my back and socks on my feet. After that day, I've only ever walked in stolen shoes.
-
-
This is a tough one
- By Julie Price on 05-01-23
By: H. D. Carlton
-
Filthy Wicked Psychos: Complete Series
- By: Eva Ashwood
- Narrated by: Cassandra Medcalf, Daniel James Lewis
- Length: 52 hrs and 49 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was the girl no one looked at twice. Until they saw me. My whole life, no one has had my back. My parents are dead, my adoptive mother is a drug addict, and the mean girls on campus mock me for my scars. So when I end up desperate for money and out of options, I agree to sell the one thing I have left: my innocence. On the night I’m meant to give my body to a brutal Russian mobster, three men storm into the room like dark shadows and kill him before he can claim me. When they drag me from the blood-soaked bed, I’m certain they’re going to kill me too.
-
-
steamy but repetitive
- By Kacee on 11-20-24
By: Eva Ashwood
-
Butcher & Blackbird
- The Ruinous Love Trilogy, Book 1
- By: Brynne Weaver
- Narrated by: Joe Arden, Lucy Rivers
- Length: 8 hrs and 43 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When a chance encounter sparks an unlikely bond between rival murderers Sloane and Rowan, the two find something elusive—the friendship of a like-minded, pitch-black soul. From small-town West Virginia to upscale California, from downtown Boston to rural Texas, the two hunters collide in an annual game of blood and suffering, one that pits them against the most dangerous monsters in the country.
-
-
Listen, I'm a 'sympathetic retcher'
- By J. Scarlyn on 10-25-23
By: Brynne Weaver
-
Den of Vipers
- By: K.A. Knight
- Narrated by: Cornell Collins, Hollie Jackson
- Length: 19 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Ryder, Garrett, Kenzo, and Diesel - The Vipers. Their deals are as sordid as their business, and their reputation is enough to bring a grown man to his knees, forcing him to beg for mercy. They are not people you mess with, yet my dad did. The old man ran up a debt with them and then sold me to cover his losses. Yes, sold me. They own me now. I’m theirs in every sense of the word. But I’ve never been meek and compliant.
-
-
Shrek
- By Shemika Holmes on 02-25-21
By: K.A. Knight
-
God of Malice
- Legacy, Book 1
- By: Rina Kent
- Narrated by: Sebastian York, Josie Minor, Aaron Shedlock, and others
- Length: 15 hrs and 30 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I caught the attention of a monster. I didn’t ask for it. Didn’t even see it coming. But the moment I do, it’s too late. Killian Carson is a predator wrapped in sophisticated charm. He’s cold-blooded, manipulative, and savage. The worst part is that no one sees his devil side. I do. And that will cost me everything. I run, but the thing about monsters? They always chase.
-
-
TEEN - DEFINITELY NOT FOR ME
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 07-15-22
By: Rina Kent
-
Sick Boys
- A Spine Ridge University Standalone
- By: Clarissa Wild
- Narrated by: Corvin King, Desireé Ketchum
- Length: 17 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The night my sister died, a piece of me died with her. So I made a vow to enroll at Spine Ridge University just like her, find the person responsible… and make them pay. Until I meet three sick boys of the Skull & Serpent Society: Felix, Dylan, Alistair. Rude, heartless, vicious guys who are obsessed with making me regret I ever stepped foot on campus. They make me a deal: My body in exchange for a glimpse at their violence.
-
-
Oh!
- By Lucid on 06-09-24
By: Clarissa Wild
-
Dante
- Chicago Ruthless, Book 1
- By: Sadie Kincaid
- Narrated by: Elena Wolfe, Tor Thom
- Length: 9 hrs and 20 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I hate Dante Moretti. He is cold, calculating, and vicious. It’s no secret that he wiped out his former fiancée and her entire family on the eve of their wedding. He’s the kind of evil that makes even devils cry. But that’s not why I hate him.
-
-
I DIDN’T LOVE IT.. BUT COULDN’T STOP LISTENING
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 09-01-23
By: Sadie Kincaid
-
Riches to Riches: Part One
- Abbs Valley, Book 1
- By: Ames Mills
- Narrated by: Ada Sinclair, Patrick Zeller
- Length: 21 hrs and 34 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When Dad died, he made me the leader of the Italian Mafia. That position was unheard of for a woman—until me. Ryder, Dex, Gage, and Holden are my team, my closest friends. Then Leo waltzes into my life, turning it upside down, along with everyone in it. One lie. One secret. That's all it took to bring it all burning down around me. Jealousy and hidden desires from the four guys I thought only saw me as their friend and boss stoke the flames even higher.
-
-
Spicyyyy 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
- By Christina Sarette on 11-26-23
By: Ames Mills
-
A Soul to Keep
- Duskwalker Brides, Book 1
- By: Opal Reyne
- Narrated by: Wolfgang Milliken, Elise Hoffman
- Length: 17 hrs and 43 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Known as a harbinger of bad omens and blamed for Demons eating her family, Reia is shunned by her entire village. When the next offering is due and the monstrous Duskwalker is seen heading their way, her village offers her an impossible choice—be thrown into the prison cells or allow herself to be sacrificed to a faceless monster.
-
-
This reads like fanfiction
- By Secretturtlepropaganda on 11-24-23
By: Opal Reyne
-
Good Bad Girl
- A Novel
- By: Alice Feeney
- Narrated by: Katherine Press, Stephanie Racine
- Length: 9 hrs and 21 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Twenty years after a baby is stolen from a stroller, a woman is murdered in a care home. The two crimes are somehow linked, and a good bad girl may be the key to discovering the truth. Edith may have been tricked into a nursing home, but at eighty-years-young, she’s planning her escape. Patience works there, cleaning messes and bonding with Edith, a kindred spirit. But Patience is lying to Edith about almost everything. Edith’s own daughter, Clio, won’t speak to her. And someone new is about to knock on Clio’s door…and their intentions aren’t good.
-
-
Finished it the day it came out
- By Sara on 08-30-23
By: Alice Feeney
-
There Are No Saints
- Sinners Duet, Book 1
- By: Sophie Lark
- Narrated by: Lee Daniels, Jeffrey Holz
- Length: 8 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I loathe Alastor Shaw. The city of San Francisco thinks we’re rival artists. In truth, we’re predators battling for hunting ground. We never chased the same prey. Until the night we both laid eyes on Mara Eldritch. Shaw wants to use her as a pawn in his twisted game. I’m fixated on her for a different reason.
-
-
A different take on the darker side
- By Lisa X on 01-10-23
By: Sophie Lark
-
Brutal Obsession
- By: S. Massery
- Narrated by: Teddy Hamilton, Heather Firth
- Length: 14 hrs and 32 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I had a foolproof plan. Finish college playing the best sport on earth. Hockey. Get drafted by an NHL team. Make my senator father at least a little proud of me. I was on track to do just that…until Violet Reece and I collided. Literally.
-
-
Did not live up to the hype
- By Lovabull Books on 04-23-23
By: S. Massery
-
Villain Era
- Sinners and Angels
- By: Luna Pierce
- Narrated by: Bridget Bordeaux, Jake Bordeaux
- Length: 12 hrs and 29 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
After our rival gives up the throne as my dying wish, my men trust him to protect me from any danger that may come my way. He keeps me safe, somehow understanding the darkness that lurks inside of me. He knows it cannot be caged, and he allows me the ability to set it free when we’re alone.
-
-
Even better listening to it!
- By Heather Douglas on 07-15-23
By: Luna Pierce
-
Dirty Crazy Bad: A Prequel Short Story
- Dirty Crazy Bad Duet
- By: Siobhan Davis™
- Narrated by: Ramona Master, Michael Gallagher
- Length: 49 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The hot stranger, who gate-crashed my party and almost came to blows with my boyfriend and my other lover, is my loathsome new stepbrother. Ares delights in telling me he’s named after the God of War, as he threatens to ruin me. Not sure what I have done to deserve his instant hatred, but whatever.
-
-
Nice!
- By valerie on 01-08-24
By: Siobhan Davis™
-
Dirty Broken Savages: Complete Series
- By: Eva Ashwood
- Narrated by: Cassandra Medcalf, Daniel James Lewis
- Length: 48 hrs and 17 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Some people wear their heart on their sleeve. I wear vengeance like a suit of armor. I’ve got a list with six names on it. Six people who wronged me, who hurt me, who took everything from me. Six people who turned me into the monster I am now. And I’ve crossed off every name but one.
-
-
Spicy RH
- By GeauxGetLit on 09-17-23
By: Eva Ashwood
-
Desperate Measures
- Wicked Villains, Book 1
- By: Katee Robert
- Narrated by: Lessa Lamb, Jack Calihan
- Length: 9 hrs and 7 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
One night, and my entire life went up in flames. All because of him. Jafar. As my world burned down around me, he offered me a choice. Walk away with nothing but my freedom...or rise to his challenge and win my fortune back. I bargained. I lost. Now Jafar owns me, and even as my mind rails against his rules, my body loves the punishments he deals out when I break them. But a gilded cage is still a prison, I’ll do anything to obtain my freedom. Even betray the man I’m falling for. Content Warning: This book contains depictions of consensual non-consent.
-
-
HORRIBLE
- By Delicia Sherrod on 06-06-21
By: Katee Robert
Related to this topic
-
The Devil
- Devil's Playground Duet, Book 1
- By: Ashley Jade
- Narrated by: Teddy Hamilton, Victoria Mei, Soren Gray
- Length: 5 hrs and 39 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
They'll tell you I seduced them. Used my looks and body to lure them into my playground. They'll tell you I'm a sinner. A demon who held them captive with temptation and lust. They'll tell you I'm evil. A monster obsessed with the both of them. They'll tell you they made a deal with the devil. What they won't tell you...is how much they liked it.
-
-
This Book Was Wicked and Addicting!
- By KMB on 10-05-19
By: Ashley Jade
-
Imperfect Monster
- A Dark Romance
- By: Jennifer Bene
- Narrated by: Danika Keane, Burke Stevens
- Length: 8 hrs and 44 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Nicky just wants to save her brother. She showed up with an envelope full of cash and a smart mouth and found herself in a den of monsters. I wish I could say I was the best of them, I wish I could protect her - but I’m far from perfect.
-
-
SORRY.. BUT IT'S A NO FROM ME
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 05-13-19
By: Jennifer Bene
-
Savior
- By: Fiona Cole
- Narrated by: Aaron Shedlock, Kathryn Lynhurst
- Length: 7 hrs and 58 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Handsome and mysterious, he swoops in to offer me a new life, but this is no knight in shining armor. He’s cold, hardened by his past. But there’s an inferno underneath the ice. I can feel the heat each time he looks at me - each time he gives in to the desire between us. No matter how much I push to unleash the fire in his eyes, he shoves back harder each time. He’s merciless with his cruel words, telling me how naive I am, how little I know of the world.
-
-
So humiliating and icky, not sexy
- By 🎧 Smoochie Reviews 🎧 on 05-12-20
By: Fiona Cole
-
Liar
- By: Fiona Cole
- Narrated by: Ava Erickson, Brian Pallino
- Length: 6 hrs and 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
He was my uncle's friend, and I was too young for him. But in the heat of the moment, against the wall in a darkened hallway of an illicit club, none of those things mattered. It was just one night of giving in to what we both wanted. I never expected to see him two years later, sitting across me during a family dinner, encouraging me to do my internship for his business.
-
-
PATHETIC heroine..Secondhand embarrassment abounds
- By Sara on 02-02-22
By: Fiona Cole
-
Bad Saint
- A Dark Romance
- By: Monica James
- Narrated by: Yvonne Syn
- Length: 9 hrs and 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was kidnapped on my honeymoon by three masked men. Blindfolded. Bound. Destination unknown. I was told to stay silent and abide by their rules. But they didn’t realize I wasn’t a victim...not anymore. The open sea was my backdrop for nine torturous days. During that time, glimmers of my fate were revealed by a man with the mysterious chartreuse-colored eyes. He should have scared me, but he didn’t. He intrigued me. And I intrigued him. He punished me when I didn’t listen, which was every single day. But beneath his cruelty, I sensed he was guarding a grave secret.
-
-
SENSATIONAL.. MYSTERY & DELICIOUSLY DARK MAYHEM
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 09-01-19
By: Monica James
-
Vow of Deception
- Deception Trilogy, Book 1
- By: Rina Kent
- Narrated by: Jason Clarke, Desiree Ketchum
- Length: 8 hrs and 4 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
My husband. My tormentor. The most notorious man in the city offers me a job. Act as his dead wife. Adrian Volkov isn’t the type of person who takes no for an answer. He commands with an iron fist and all his orders are met. When he approaches me with the offer, I have two options. Go to prison or put myself under his wrath. I choose to have a roof over my head. What’s so hard about acting, right? Wrong. The moment I step into his wife’s shoes, everything spirals out of control. My only way of survival is through Adrian. Or is it?
-
-
10⭐️ PERFECTION ALL THE WAY.. until the cliffhanger
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 03-12-21
By: Rina Kent
-
The Devil
- Devil's Playground Duet, Book 1
- By: Ashley Jade
- Narrated by: Teddy Hamilton, Victoria Mei, Soren Gray
- Length: 5 hrs and 39 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
They'll tell you I seduced them. Used my looks and body to lure them into my playground. They'll tell you I'm a sinner. A demon who held them captive with temptation and lust. They'll tell you I'm evil. A monster obsessed with the both of them. They'll tell you they made a deal with the devil. What they won't tell you...is how much they liked it.
-
-
This Book Was Wicked and Addicting!
- By KMB on 10-05-19
By: Ashley Jade
-
Imperfect Monster
- A Dark Romance
- By: Jennifer Bene
- Narrated by: Danika Keane, Burke Stevens
- Length: 8 hrs and 44 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Nicky just wants to save her brother. She showed up with an envelope full of cash and a smart mouth and found herself in a den of monsters. I wish I could say I was the best of them, I wish I could protect her - but I’m far from perfect.
-
-
SORRY.. BUT IT'S A NO FROM ME
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 05-13-19
By: Jennifer Bene
-
Savior
- By: Fiona Cole
- Narrated by: Aaron Shedlock, Kathryn Lynhurst
- Length: 7 hrs and 58 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Handsome and mysterious, he swoops in to offer me a new life, but this is no knight in shining armor. He’s cold, hardened by his past. But there’s an inferno underneath the ice. I can feel the heat each time he looks at me - each time he gives in to the desire between us. No matter how much I push to unleash the fire in his eyes, he shoves back harder each time. He’s merciless with his cruel words, telling me how naive I am, how little I know of the world.
-
-
So humiliating and icky, not sexy
- By 🎧 Smoochie Reviews 🎧 on 05-12-20
By: Fiona Cole
-
Liar
- By: Fiona Cole
- Narrated by: Ava Erickson, Brian Pallino
- Length: 6 hrs and 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
He was my uncle's friend, and I was too young for him. But in the heat of the moment, against the wall in a darkened hallway of an illicit club, none of those things mattered. It was just one night of giving in to what we both wanted. I never expected to see him two years later, sitting across me during a family dinner, encouraging me to do my internship for his business.
-
-
PATHETIC heroine..Secondhand embarrassment abounds
- By Sara on 02-02-22
By: Fiona Cole
-
Bad Saint
- A Dark Romance
- By: Monica James
- Narrated by: Yvonne Syn
- Length: 9 hrs and 31 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was kidnapped on my honeymoon by three masked men. Blindfolded. Bound. Destination unknown. I was told to stay silent and abide by their rules. But they didn’t realize I wasn’t a victim...not anymore. The open sea was my backdrop for nine torturous days. During that time, glimmers of my fate were revealed by a man with the mysterious chartreuse-colored eyes. He should have scared me, but he didn’t. He intrigued me. And I intrigued him. He punished me when I didn’t listen, which was every single day. But beneath his cruelty, I sensed he was guarding a grave secret.
-
-
SENSATIONAL.. MYSTERY & DELICIOUSLY DARK MAYHEM
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 09-01-19
By: Monica James
-
Vow of Deception
- Deception Trilogy, Book 1
- By: Rina Kent
- Narrated by: Jason Clarke, Desiree Ketchum
- Length: 8 hrs and 4 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
My husband. My tormentor. The most notorious man in the city offers me a job. Act as his dead wife. Adrian Volkov isn’t the type of person who takes no for an answer. He commands with an iron fist and all his orders are met. When he approaches me with the offer, I have two options. Go to prison or put myself under his wrath. I choose to have a roof over my head. What’s so hard about acting, right? Wrong. The moment I step into his wife’s shoes, everything spirals out of control. My only way of survival is through Adrian. Or is it?
-
-
10⭐️ PERFECTION ALL THE WAY.. until the cliffhanger
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 03-12-21
By: Rina Kent
-
The Queen of Carnage
- Underestimated, Book 1
- By: Candice Wright
- Narrated by: Lucy Rivers
- Length: 7 hrs and 41 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
After getting tangled up in Carnage business, it isn’t long before I'm tangled up in their sheets. They see is my blonde hair and sweet smile, and they want to dirty me up a little. I'm a splash of pink within the leather-clad army, standing out like a tampon in a condom factory. But it’s not my fault they underestimated me. I might like girly things, but I’m much more likely to spray you with bullets then sprinkle you with glitter. I could just tell them they have me labeled all wrong...but where’s the fun in that?
-
-
Great book!
- By desi on 08-21-21
By: Candice Wright
-
Santori
- By: Maris Black
- Narrated by: J.F. Harding
- Length: 7 hrs and 29 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Michael Kage Santori has just inherited a thriving hotel and millions of dollars. He’s poised to become an MMA champion. Things couldn’t be better between him and his college boy lover, Jamie Atwood - especially in the bedroom, where Jamie is more than eager to let Kage take out his aggressions on him. Kage seems to have it all, but success and happiness have come at a steep price. After all of the childhood trauma he endured at the hands of his controlling uncle, Peter Santori, it’s a miracle Kage has any shred of sanity left. And now, because of him, Jamie is a murderer.
-
-
Oddly constructed but compelling serial installment
- By Cranky Reader on 04-13-19
By: Maris Black
-
Flock
- The Ravenhood, Book 1
- By: Kate Stewart
- Narrated by: Maxine Mitchell, Joe Arden
- Length: 10 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Triple Falls wasn’t at all what it seemed, nor were the men that swept me under their wing. But in order to keep them, I had to be in on their secrets. Secrets that cost us everything to keep. That’s the novelty of fiction versus reality. You can’t re-live your own love story, because by the time you’ve realized you’re living it, it’s over. At least that was the case for me and the men I trusted my foolish heart to. Looking back, I’m convinced I willed my story into existence, due to my illness, and all were punished.
-
-
Y’ALL!
- By Justin McNulty on 05-14-21
By: Kate Stewart
-
A Girl Like Her
- By: Talia Hibbert
- Narrated by: Rupert Channing
- Length: 7 hrs and 54 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
After years of military service, Evan Miller wants a quiet life. The small town of Ravenswood seems perfect - until he stumbles upon a vicious web of lies with his new neighbor at its center. Ruth Kabbah is rude, awkward, and - according to everyone in town - bad news. Thing is, no one will tell Evan why. Does she perform ritual sacrifices? Howl at the moon? Pour the milk before the tea? He has no clue. But he desperately wants to find out. The more Evan’s isolated, eccentric neighbor pushes him away, the more he wants her.
-
-
A Love Story - plain and simple
- By LexiLikesLiterature on 02-16-19
By: Talia Hibbert
-
Greed
- A Sinful Empire, Book 1
- By: Eva Charles
- Narrated by: Heather Stonewell, Gregory Salinas
- Length: 11 hrs and 26 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Some girls grow up in castles with fortresses to protect them from monsters. Other girls grow up in castles with fortresses to protect the monsters. I am both of these girls.
-
-
Daniela and Antonio
- By Vicki on 05-28-24
By: Eva Charles
-
Shark's Edge
- Shark's Edge, Book 1
- By: Angel Payne, Victoria Blue
- Narrated by: Jacob Morgan, Erin Mallon
- Length: 8 hrs and 13 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Sebastian Shark is on the verge of realizing his dream. The Edge - the most luxurious Los Angeles skyscraper ever conceived - will be his legacy, an icon to dominate LA’s skyline just as Shark dominates its boardrooms. Self-made businesswoman Abbigail Gibson is on a trajectory toward massive success, but to get there, she must navigate the egos of her demanding clients - particularly the driven and obstinate Shark, who possesses the special talent of aggravating and arousing her within the same breath.
-
-
A great start to a classic Contemporary Romance
- By Carey Sabala on 12-12-19
By: Angel Payne, and others
People who viewed this also viewed...
-
Sinful Crown
- By: Ava Harrison
- Narrated by: Jacob Morgan, Stella Hunter
- Length: 9 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
My protector is a monster. Evil men are searching for me. Gideon Byrne is my salvation. Cold. Cruel. And handsome beyond measure. He should scare me. His possessive desire should make me run. But I stay. I give in to him. I give him…me. I’m falling in love with a monster. And I refuse to stop.
-
-
Another Win For Ava!
- By C. Y. on 02-12-23
By: Ava Harrison
-
Counts of Eight
- The Four Families, Book 1
- By: Brynn Ford
- Narrated by: Elle Sonali, Jeffrey Holz
- Length: 9 hrs and 11 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I've served the four families since I was kidnapped three years ago. I've accepted my fate, knowing that escape is impossible. My villainous master abuses me, but I've learned to live this lonely life. I've become complacent in my misery…then my master brings home another captive for me to train, and his presence changes everything.
-
-
Counts of Eight so amazing
- By Amanda T on 11-17-22
By: Brynn Ford
-
The Shadows
- The Darkness Trilogy, Book One
- By: Rebecca Hamby
- Narrated by: Rebecca Hamby, Guy Barnes
- Length: 6 hrs and 13 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was taken. Taken from the world I created for myself. I’m not alone, I’m one of many girls locked in this castle awaiting something. We’re to be sold like animals for slaughter to rich men who will do God knows what to us. I won’t let this happen.
-
-
LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!!
- By Kindle Customer on 10-23-23
By: Rebecca Hamby
-
Catalyst
- Heart of the Inferno, Book 1
- By: Nicole Fanning
- Narrated by: Maxine Mitchell, Grayson Owens
- Length: 16 hrs and 29 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When Natalie Tyler arrives in Chicago to attend her cousin's wedding, she is just hoping to survive the week with her estranged family...and her ex-fiancé. One week. One uneventful week at the beautiful Hotel Jefferson is all she has to endure before she can return to her quiet life in Miami. However, fate has other plans.
-
-
ADDICTIVE & WONDERFUL… but trilogy cliffhanger
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 07-19-23
By: Nicole Fanning
-
Triple Threat
- Deception Duet, Book 1
- By: K Webster
- Narrated by: Sarah Puckett, Teddy Hamilton
- Length: 7 hrs and 3 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I’m a prisoner in a prestigious world; a perfect princess locked in a tower. My father will never let me go. Not that I could leave. I would never abandon my little sister. Hope comes in the form of a devilishly handsome man with dark eyes and darker secrets. With each encounter, I’m lured deeper into the labyrinth. The danger lurking beneath his surface calls to me, even as it warns me away. Except there’s a new side of him every time we meet. A different danger each time we touch.
-
-
female narrator ruins this book
- By penny kearns on 08-02-22
By: K Webster
-
The Heart of a Monster: The Complete Series
- By: Eva Chase
- Narrated by: Amber Lee Connors, Aiden Snow
- Length: 34 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Every beat of my heart is the tick of a time bomb, reminding me to squeeze as many thrills out of life as I can. A horde of nightmarish monsters jumping me in the middle of the night? Nope, that's too much even for me. So when three demonic figures leap out of the shadows to my defense, my choices are trust my unexpected champions... or die. Not exactly a tough decision. The beastly men wrench me away from my home, claiming they'll keep me safe. They say there's something special about me—something the others want to devour and they mean to protect.
-
-
The Heart of a Monster
- By AshReads on 06-25-24
By: Eva Chase
-
Sinful Crown
- By: Ava Harrison
- Narrated by: Jacob Morgan, Stella Hunter
- Length: 9 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
My protector is a monster. Evil men are searching for me. Gideon Byrne is my salvation. Cold. Cruel. And handsome beyond measure. He should scare me. His possessive desire should make me run. But I stay. I give in to him. I give him…me. I’m falling in love with a monster. And I refuse to stop.
-
-
Another Win For Ava!
- By C. Y. on 02-12-23
By: Ava Harrison
-
Counts of Eight
- The Four Families, Book 1
- By: Brynn Ford
- Narrated by: Elle Sonali, Jeffrey Holz
- Length: 9 hrs and 11 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I've served the four families since I was kidnapped three years ago. I've accepted my fate, knowing that escape is impossible. My villainous master abuses me, but I've learned to live this lonely life. I've become complacent in my misery…then my master brings home another captive for me to train, and his presence changes everything.
-
-
Counts of Eight so amazing
- By Amanda T on 11-17-22
By: Brynn Ford
-
The Shadows
- The Darkness Trilogy, Book One
- By: Rebecca Hamby
- Narrated by: Rebecca Hamby, Guy Barnes
- Length: 6 hrs and 13 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was taken. Taken from the world I created for myself. I’m not alone, I’m one of many girls locked in this castle awaiting something. We’re to be sold like animals for slaughter to rich men who will do God knows what to us. I won’t let this happen.
-
-
LOVE LOVE LOVE!!!!
- By Kindle Customer on 10-23-23
By: Rebecca Hamby
-
Catalyst
- Heart of the Inferno, Book 1
- By: Nicole Fanning
- Narrated by: Maxine Mitchell, Grayson Owens
- Length: 16 hrs and 29 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When Natalie Tyler arrives in Chicago to attend her cousin's wedding, she is just hoping to survive the week with her estranged family...and her ex-fiancé. One week. One uneventful week at the beautiful Hotel Jefferson is all she has to endure before she can return to her quiet life in Miami. However, fate has other plans.
-
-
ADDICTIVE & WONDERFUL… but trilogy cliffhanger
- By CAROLYN 🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹🔹 on 07-19-23
By: Nicole Fanning
-
Triple Threat
- Deception Duet, Book 1
- By: K Webster
- Narrated by: Sarah Puckett, Teddy Hamilton
- Length: 7 hrs and 3 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I’m a prisoner in a prestigious world; a perfect princess locked in a tower. My father will never let me go. Not that I could leave. I would never abandon my little sister. Hope comes in the form of a devilishly handsome man with dark eyes and darker secrets. With each encounter, I’m lured deeper into the labyrinth. The danger lurking beneath his surface calls to me, even as it warns me away. Except there’s a new side of him every time we meet. A different danger each time we touch.
-
-
female narrator ruins this book
- By penny kearns on 08-02-22
By: K Webster
-
The Heart of a Monster: The Complete Series
- By: Eva Chase
- Narrated by: Amber Lee Connors, Aiden Snow
- Length: 34 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Every beat of my heart is the tick of a time bomb, reminding me to squeeze as many thrills out of life as I can. A horde of nightmarish monsters jumping me in the middle of the night? Nope, that's too much even for me. So when three demonic figures leap out of the shadows to my defense, my choices are trust my unexpected champions... or die. Not exactly a tough decision. The beastly men wrench me away from my home, claiming they'll keep me safe. They say there's something special about me—something the others want to devour and they mean to protect.
-
-
The Heart of a Monster
- By AshReads on 06-25-24
By: Eva Chase
-
The Story of Us
- Carnage, Book 1
- By: Lesley Jones
- Narrated by: Nikki Delgado
- Length: 12 hrs and 42 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
A story about a boy who dreamed of rock and roll. A story about a girl who dreamed about a boy. An epic, all-consuming love story about betrayal, loss and learning, that spans over 20 years. This is the story of us: "I was just 11 years old, but I knew without a shadow of a doubt I was staring into the eyes of the boy I was going to love forever." An edgy coming-of-age love story that breaks all the rules and transcends the decades.
-
-
Is This What Romance Novels Have Come To??
- By Wendi on 06-12-24
By: Lesley Jones
-
Betrayal
- Corrupt Empire Series, Book 1
- By: Sarah Bailey
- Narrated by: Hugh Carter
- Length: 8 hrs
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
It all started one dark night. The last night I saw my family. The night I met him. The only man to haunt my every moment. I witnessed something I was never meant to see. He took me. He broke me. He made me his. And now he wants to use me to bring down my family.
-
-
Loved the story and the narrator
- By The 1000 Lives of Sherlock Hughes on 07-15-20
By: Sarah Bailey
-
Savage Kings
- Savages of Kingsworth, Book 1
- By: L.M. Harrison
- Narrated by: Kasi Hollowell
- Length: 11 hrs and 50 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Three beautiful, cruel men rule Kingsworth. And I'm the girl who almost ruined them. It all started with that video I posted of them—you know, the one that went viral—but that was before I knew who they were. Ezra Covington, Bellamy Thorn, and Dashiell Laurier. Three untouchable royals who were just…well, royally touched. Three gorgeous, ruthless kings used to getting exactly what they want. Now they want me.
-
-
Could not put it down
- By Flowers Children on 08-17-23
By: L.M. Harrison
-
Devil You Hate
- A Dark Mafia Romance (The Diavolo Crime Family Series, Book 1)
- By: J. L. Beck, Cassandra Hallman
- Narrated by: Devon Grace, Zachary Johnson
- Length: 8 hrs and 20 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Deranged and violent. Gorgeous but frightening. I’m a businessman, so when one of my debtors offers me his fiancé in exchange for a debt settled, I figure why not? The woman will be a quick sell. Repayment comes in the form of a beautiful but haunted young woman. The light in her tempts the darkness inside of me. Teases it, tortures it. I want to hurt her. I want to break her. I want to keep her. Luckily for Celia, she fails to see that there is no goodness in me.
-
-
Whew! Be Ready!
- By Mint Mocha on 01-03-24
By: J. L. Beck, and others
-
Dark Island Scots: Complete Series
- By: Jolie Vines
- Narrated by: Zara Hampton-Brown, Zachary Webber
- Length: 37 hrs and 40 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Binge-listen to the complete Dark Island Scots series in one glossy audio boxed set. All the cliffhangers answered. All the steam, drama, and dark mystery ready for you in one delicious package.
-
-
wasted my money
- By Monroe and Natas on 10-03-24
By: Jolie Vines
-
Filthy Wicked Psychos: Complete Series
- By: Eva Ashwood
- Narrated by: Cassandra Medcalf, Daniel James Lewis
- Length: 52 hrs and 49 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
I was the girl no one looked at twice. Until they saw me. My whole life, no one has had my back. My parents are dead, my adoptive mother is a drug addict, and the mean girls on campus mock me for my scars. So when I end up desperate for money and out of options, I agree to sell the one thing I have left: my innocence. On the night I’m meant to give my body to a brutal Russian mobster, three men storm into the room like dark shadows and kill him before he can claim me. When they drag me from the blood-soaked bed, I’m certain they’re going to kill me too.
-
-
steamy but repetitive
- By Kacee on 11-20-24
By: Eva Ashwood
-
The Ritual
- By: Shantel Tessier
- Narrated by: Aiden Snow, Meg Sylvan
- Length: 16 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Barrington University is home of the Lords, a secret society that requires their blood in payment. They are above all—the most powerful men in the world. They devote their lives to violence in exchange for power. And during their senior year, they are offered a chosen one.
-
-
Waste of a credit!!
- By delsea on 05-18-23
By: Shantel Tessier
-
Wicked Heart
- Wreck & Ruin, Book 1
- By: Ria Wilde
- Narrated by: James Joseph, Zara Hampton Brown
- Length: 9 hrs
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
There is no room for sweet or innocent in my world. No room for mistakes or weaknesses. My life was full of darkness, greed, and corruption. Blood was spilled as easily as water and life taken without much thought. I made a vow to my sister that the people who harmed her all those years ago would pay, and the only currency I would accept was their lives. Until she arrived.
-
-
Get the Audiobook❤️
- By Rebecca B on 09-01-23
By: Ria Wilde
-
Immortal Curse Series, Books 1-3
- By: Lexi C. Foss
- Narrated by: Sarah Puckett, Kale Williams, Anais Inara Chase, and others
- Length: 35 hrs and 28 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
"What are you wearing under this dress?" he asked, his mouth brushing hers, the words whisper-soft. Not what she expected him to say. "E-excuse me?" His teeth sank into her lower lip, making her yelp. "Focus." On what? The demon club? The humans dying downstairs? The fact that you're a f--king vampire? Where should I begin? He sighed, his forehead falling to hers. "Astasiya, we have very little time to sort this before the Conclave. I need you to work with me. Both our lives depend on it. What are you wearing?"
-
-
Worth the credit 👍🏻
- By M La Monda on 02-03-23
By: Lexi C. Foss
-
Devils' Day Party
- By: C.M. Stunich
- Narrated by: Michelle Sparks, Matt Walton
- Length: 15 hrs and 26 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Hot bullies, busted cars, and the party of the year. On an endless loop. I don’t know how, but I’m living today over and over again. Every year, the town of Devil Springs holds a celebration known as Devils’ Day. There’s no magic, but there might as well be: We wear masks, we play tricks, we party hard. Every year, the students of Crescent Reform School party the hardest. They’re the lewdest, the most wanton, ribald, and lascivious.
-
-
I felt like I'm in a movie 🎥 so cool and unique ❤
- By Hannah Danielle Scofield (Justagirlandherbook21 - Bookstagram) on 06-07-23
By: C.M. Stunich
-
A Shadow of Betrayal
- Umbra Hunters, Book 1
- By: B.M. Clemton
- Narrated by: Michelle Sparks, Corvin King, Grayson Owens, and others
- Length: 11 hrs and 47 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Monsters exist. The only problem is… I'm the only one that can see them. I always thought I would outgrow it. That one day, I would magically wake up, and the nightmares that haunt my life would suddenly be gone. Unfortunately, that hasn't been my luck. Avoidance is key. Don't look at them. Pretend they aren't lurking in the shadows, and never make eye contact. But what happens when the events of my life spiral out of control, plunging me into a new world full of magic, death, and chaos?
-
-
Fullcast Duet narration. (Not dual)
- By Dusty Rays on 11-04-24
By: B.M. Clemton
-
Riches to Riches: Part One
- Abbs Valley, Book 1
- By: Ames Mills
- Narrated by: Ada Sinclair, Patrick Zeller
- Length: 21 hrs and 34 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When Dad died, he made me the leader of the Italian Mafia. That position was unheard of for a woman—until me. Ryder, Dex, Gage, and Holden are my team, my closest friends. Then Leo waltzes into my life, turning it upside down, along with everyone in it. One lie. One secret. That's all it took to bring it all burning down around me. Jealousy and hidden desires from the four guys I thought only saw me as their friend and boss stoke the flames even higher.
-
-
Spicyyyy 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
- By Christina Sarette on 11-26-23
By: Ames Mills
What listeners say about Carnage
Average customer ratingsReviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Ben
- 12-13-23
Amazing series
I love this story so much. David William Keegan does a marvelous at separating the characters. He changes his voice for each male role and it makes the book that much better!
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Anonymous User
- 03-03-23
One of my favorite series
I love these characters so much! I couldn’t get enough of this when I read it the first time, I’m so excited to get to experience it all over again in audio now🥰
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
1 person found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Hannah Williams
- 10-02-23
Can’t put it down
At first the voices made it hard for me.. but as soon as you get past that, you can’t stop, all 4 books were superb! Hot scenes, good storyline, great character build. Good ending..
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Awilda Mercedes
- 03-19-23
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Re-read if this amazing series! Can’t wait for the rest of the books, does end in a cliffhanger
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Meag Russell
- 08-01-24
Ok I am hooked
I don’t know why this has been on my TBR for so long! Just read it!
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Stephanie K. Higgins
- 02-19-23
Yes, yes, yes. ❤️🔥
I found someone recommending this book on Book-tok and I have never been so happy I used a credit. I listen to close to 20 books a month and this one takes the cake for 2023. Yes, I am calling it now. Haha
There are quite a few things that may trigger delicate souls, but for me this book was perfect. There are a few gaps in the timeline but the author seems to be filling those gaps in her own way. I immediately ran to Amazon to buy the whole series. (Since the first of the four is the only one on audible.) The narration is top notch and the dual narration did a wonderful job bringing this book to life! The female narrator had convincing job of fear with a very specific lilt to her voice. The male narrator had no problem coming across as alpha in every way. I can’t wait to get the rest of the books in the series, I have a feeling this will end up a repeat read/listen, like Den of Vipers.
Potential triggers: SA, DV, CA and Kidnapping.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
2 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Brit
- 05-24-23
Finally on audio
I was so obsessed when I read these but to hear it makes me so happy.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Amazon Customer
- 05-06-23
Underwhelmed.
If you’re looking for some hot scenes… this book has it. But the storyline isn’t much to be excited about. The plot felt slow and wasn’t very intriguing.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Ashley H
- 09-24-23
Fantastic story
I loved the entire series. It was a little off putting that the voices of the four horsemen in my mind did not match the narrator’s voice at all but the story itself is so worth working through off putting smokers rasp voice.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Colleen Townsend
- 04-16-23
Great addition to my library
I have read these books countless times & now I’m excited to listen to them as well. I’m excited for the rest of the series to come
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!