Loved it absolutely amazing

The book was just incredible and I would highly recommend reading if you like aviation and the Vietnam war.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Better editing needed

Written by someone obviously and justifiably proud of his service. The stories are interesting but suffer somewhat from the repetition of non-essential details such as the process of preparing for a mission which is repeated unnecessarily in each story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Duty, Honor, Country

Would you consider the audio edition of Warriors at 500 Knots to be better than the print version?

Dick Hill's narration brings the book alive and makes you feel as though you're in the back seat of the F-4 flying combat missions in Vietnam. Through his words, you share in the life and death decisions aircrews make on a daily basis, often times in split seconds.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Warriors at 500 Knots?

While there are many great moments in Robert's book, the most memorable one was the mining operation on the Ho Chi Minh Trail. As a retired Air Force pilot myself, flying 500 knots at 500 feet through a hail of enemy gunfire takes immense courage and dedication to mission. Taking battle damage, which forced multiple high "G" pitch ups, followed by high "G" pitch downs, then recovering the aircraft shows superior airmanship and coolness under fire.

What about Dick Hill’s performance did you like?

The correct pronunciation and annunciation of unfamiliar Air Force flying terms and acronyms, plus the reader's pacing of and emphasis on events leads to unforgettable drama that makes the reader want more.

If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?

Experience the real life drama of F-4 pilots flying combat missions under the most difficult of circumstances. Know the fear and joy of aerial flight as you ride along at 500 knots, pulling high "G" turns in afterburner, while dodging enemy gunfire, knowing that weather obscures near by mountain tops.

Any additional comments?

Robert Kirk's book brings to life the experiences of ordinary men, some exceptional, some flawed, as they grapple with the realities of combat. The book doesn't glorify war or the military. Rather, the book takes an in-depth look at the men who risked their lives on a daily basis. These men did this not for glory, but for each other--their only goal to complete each mission successfully then go home at the end of their tours. This is a must read for anyone who wants to experience the courage and raw emotions Air Force pilots experienced fighting an unpopular war. In the end, the author answers the question, "Where do we get such men."

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Another tortuous listen because of the narrator.

Over dramatic and makes all the voices sound as if the participants are either retarded or from New York or Arkansas. Cmon. Just freaking read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Great Material

I loved the material. As a 26 year Air Force veteran who's known a lot of fighter pilots, I enjoyed the "there I was" stories. Kirk's firsthand familiarity with the subject shows, and he does a great job of putting you in the cockpits and minds of the aircrews. His storytelling style is warm and familiar to people like myself who have heard friends share stories over beer and finger foods. One of the anecdotes that I chuckled at most was the one that related the challenges of flying an out-of-rig F-4 across the Pacific, having to fight the jet the whole way by keeping constant pressure on the stick to hold it level because they didn't want to admit to the problem and be stuck somewhere on the way home...maintainers who've noted how often jets fly "Code 1" on redeployment sorties understand this kind of thing. At one point during an air refueling, the pilot made an unexpected stick movement during an air refueling and the boom operator complained. Not wanting to admit to the ongoing struggle with his flight controls, the pilot apologized and said "I was just scratching my nose." That's when I started chuckling...it's the kind of tongue-in-cheek, downplaying comment a fighter pilot would make, but he wouldn't say "nose" -- I know a "mixed company" edit of a "there I was" story when I hear one. Things like that drew me closer to the author.

Dick Hill's narration, however, was somewhat off-putting from my personal perspective. Hill is a very talented and accomplished narrator, but fighter pilots have a particular way of using the language in terms of tone, inflections, mannerisms, etc. and cockpit communication is a style all its own. When they push the mic button, it's calm, precise, and almost robotic, even in stressful situations. When you've spent two and a half decades hearing the real thing, Hill's dramatization seems exaggerated and it creates a sense of auditory vertigo. The words are fighter pilot words, but the voice being used isn't even close to fighter pilot...it's like what Hollywood thinks fighter pilots sound like. So to my biased and overly-sensitive ear, Hill tended to sound somewhere between J. Peterman and the Skipper from the Madagascar Penguins. Most people would think I'm being picky, but it's like a veteran watching a war movie and latching onto the crush of a cap, position of a piece of gear, way a firearm is handled, or how someone says "good morning." It took a bit to get used to, but I let go of my biases and enjoyed the book. If Hill read cockpit communication as it is typically delivered in the real world, it would've been more accurate but far less entertaining for most people.

Overall, the book isn't Faulkner, nor is it intended to be. It's a collection of stories to pay tribute to F-4 pilots, and as such it's solid entertainment for anyone interested in the military or aviation history. It's appeal is in its unvarnished frankness and familiarity.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

9 people found this helpful

Great flying book, but...

The person who read it speaks to slow for a pilot story. Pilots usually speak fast when flying. The accent sound is not for this story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Lots or stories, lots of repetition

Would you try another book from Robert F Kirk and/or Dick Hill?

Probably so, but I would carefully read the reviews on multiple sites and try to find out the actual structure of the "book." I've listened to Dick Hill before and he's a good narrator, but this "book" has so many characters and situations, it really needed several different readers to break it up more.
Clearly a lot of the short stories that comprise this book are real, names changed, etc., but why set it all up as fiction. Either get the rights from the pilots and crews or else weave this whole thing into a larger book about a squadron, wing, etc.
Since these are all "stand-alone" short stories, there is a lot of repetition of pre-flight, takeoff roll, talking to FAC, ejection sequence, etc. This is made even worse by using the same callsigns and same crew names almost for every flight.
I was on the ground and I've heard and talked to enough different callsigns from fast-movers to populate this book. Also surprised at hearing pretty much the same ordnance all the time, and never hearing a load referred to as "snake-n-nape" though we heard that plenty.

This clearly does not compare with "Fighter Squadron at Guadalcanal" by Max Brand or "Fighter Pilot" by Robin Olds, or the three "Punk" books by Ward Carroll.

If you’ve listened to books by Robert F Kirk before, how does this one compare?

n/a

Did the narration match the pace of the story?

Mostly. Dick Hill did okay with what he had, but there should have been multiple narrators for this bag of short stories.

Do you think Warriors at 500 Knots needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

NO! Not unless Kirk is actually going to write some original content, create and give life to some characters with different names and blend it into a cohesive story. He clearly has the experience to do so.

Any additional comments?

The stories are good in themselves, but use different names, callsigns, and such so we "buy into" that crew a little. These are all anonymous aircrews and their story, good, bad, brave, tragic is over in few minutes. It really looks like this was a collection of anecdotes and experiences looking for a container. With a good writer and editor, this could have worked well. The fact that it does not, is no reflection on the brave men who risked it all on a daily basis.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Great Read

Would you consider the audio edition of Warriors at 500 Knots to be better than the print version?

I thought both were great. The narrator in the audio version did a great job. His voice, in my opinion, lent itself to the book at hand and the material that was being read. For me, the varying tone and inflection of the narrator made it more lifelike. Whether it was hearing about the first mission and the feeling of going into the unknown, a plane going down and thinking about the emotions of losing crew members, or to the trip home knowing the pilots (and all of the military personnel involved) gave all they could to defend our country, I was engaged throughout.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Many moments moved me. With so many details of what was going on and the surroundings the author provided (from real life experiences the author was able to glean from), it gave me the opportunity to, in my imagination, put me right there in that jet. I could feel the varied emotions the author was conveying at every turn of the page.

Any additional comments?

A great book! I have recommended this to others (especially the audiobook format) including my sons who have a great interest in the military, flying and of our country's past.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

I liked it and would read it again

I love every book so far read by Dick Hill.
The story was pretty cool, a nice collection of short anecdotes that make you feel a little what it was like for the airmen operating in Vietnam.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

worth the read

great material. only downside was having all the verbal exchanges played by a Howard Cosell-like voice.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!