Great Book!

What a great book! Looking at reviews this book seems often to be pigeonholed as a book by a Jew and about Jews almost implying that it is for Jews. This is a great travesty. That’s like saying Crime and Punishment is by a Russian and for Russians, or Ulysses is by the Irish and for the Irish. This is a wonderful book about greed, oppression, and men pushed to the limits of life. Some parts are heavy and dark, some tender and loving, and often laced with bits of humor. I don’t think anyone will truly like the Ashkenazi’s, but I for one respect them in the same way as the protagonist of other great works. It will forever be in my group of favorite books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

okay read

it was an interesting view on the times and culture. The reader's mispronouncing Jewish holidays & some Yiddish words bothered me, though.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

One of My Best in Years

What an excellent book. Well written. It reminds me of one of the classic Russian novels in scope and character development but with a Jewish focus. Highly recommended!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

As good a listen as you'll find, & Insightful

If you could sum up The Brothers Ashkenazi in three words, what would they be?

Marxism, Anti-Semitism, & Life

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Brothers Ashkenazi?

Nissam the Depraved's moment of understanding that the values he worked so hard for were undermined by the various tendancies of man.

What about Stefan Rudnicki’s performance did you like?

Great knack for capturing the feel of his characters.

Who was the most memorable character of The Brothers Ashkenazi and why?

Max, Jacob, Tevia the lawless, Nissam

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Historical fiction at its finest

The story of three generations of the Ashkenazi family and set in 19th and 20th Eastern Europe, its themes are specific to that time and place, yet also universal. Illuminates the clash between traditional Judaism and the Jewish enlightenment, orthodoxy and progress, capitalism and workers rights, accepting the world as it is and risking your life to change it.

Good narration, with the exception of mangling some of the Yiddish.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Suffering in History

I learned a great deal about the history of Lodz, Poland, in “The Brothers Ashkenazi.” The 1935 novel is an absorbing family saga played out against the turbulent history of Lodz (“Woodj” in the narrator’s pronunciation). The tale is Dickensian or Tolstoian in its panoramic view of Jewish society in Poland, from impoverished textile workers to intense Marxists to the ostentatious families of the factory owners. Few characters are happy. Violence is common, whether in early uprisings against the wealthy or anti-Jewish pogroms. The outside world—the reign of Czar Alexander III, the Russo-Japanese War and especially World War I—have profound impacts on Lodz. There is routine corruption, bribery, greed and hypocrisy. The most shocking thing, however, is the knowledge that all these characters and their descendants would be murdered by the Nazis in World War II. In that regard, it reminded me of “Never Let Me Go” by Kazuo Ishiguro, in which the young schoolmates share their discoveries, joys and sorrows, knowing but not really understanding that they are all doomed. Overall, this was a disturbing but resonant novel.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Time Capsule of Jewish Life in Poland

Written during the 1930s, this book by I.J. Singer, older brother of Nobel Prize winner Isaac Bashevis Singer, proves to be a remarkable look back at Jewish life in Poland during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. What makes it so remarkable is that it was written before the Holocaust and is therefore not seen through the prism of that horrific event.

The Brothers Ashkenazi presages the Holocaust without knowing that it was about to happen. But more importantly, it is a complete examination of what life was like for Jews in Lodz without being tempered in its honesty by the subsequent advent of the Lodz Ghetto and its brutal dissolution by the Nazis (my father was forced into the Lodz Ghetto as a teenager, then deported to Auschwitz).

The breadth and depth of Singer's book is epic. Orthodoxy goes up against assimilation, capitalism has its inevitable collision with communism, Jews clash with Poles who clash with Germans who clash with Russians, and everyone seems to hate the Latvians and Lithuanians. There is also an unexpected look at feminist issues via the practice of arranged (read: forced) marriages.

The Brothers Ashkenazi is breathtaking -- in scope, pace, and characterization -- from the start when German refugees of the Napoleonic wars (not Jews, Germans) settled in Lodz, through the Industrial Revolution, the rise of unionism and socialism, economic ups and downs, the German occupation during the first World War, the Russian Revolution, and the outburst of extremely virulent and violent anti-Semitism after the war that had rarely occurred prior to then.

Despite its title, this book is really about one of the two brothers, Max. As fascinating as his experiences are, he is such a despicable character that you want to forget him as quickly as possible. There are myriad other characters that compare and contrast to Max in deed and temperament, starting with his much more likable twin brother and including his maligned first wife, not to mention his father and his business partners and his competitors and his workers, etc. etc.

Most memorable of all is Nissan. He is a relatively minor figure compared to Max, but he is the true counterpoint. Both start out as rabbinical students, both turn against their fathers, but that is where the similarities end. Where Max is the ultimate exploiter of people, both as an industrialist and in his personal life, Nissan is the idealist. Where Max is the capitalist who embraces apostasy as a negotiating ploy, Nissan is an apostate who embraces socialism and communism for their humanistic ideals.

The scenes where Nissan and Max collide are among the best in the book. Nissan is the only person who can honestly tell Max where to get off. Even when Max talks sense about the economic realities of capitalism (e.g. the profit motive as a driver of innovation and investment), Nissan knows just how to reject him. When Max tries to make nice to Nissan (in his own self-interest, of course), Nissan's rejoinder is devastating in its directness and simplicity.

Unlike Max, Nissan devotes himself selflessly to the cause of the working class, enduring beatings and prison sentences and humiliation in pursuit of that cause. How these contrasting characters fare in the aftermath of the Russian Revolution is (trying to avoid spoilers) yet another contrast in just desserts (or not). Based on the afterword, Nissan's experience in rejecting his rabbinical father's Orthodox Judaism early in life and communism in the immediate aftermath of the Revolution mirrors that of the author.

This book has been called the best Russian novel ever written in Yiddish. It was popular enough in its day to battle it out with Gone With the Wind for the top spot on the NY Times best seller list. It's like the Downton Abbey of Polish Jews, but with even more heartache and violence because of the anti-Semitic pogroms that are so vividly depicted. Written in Yiddish, narrator Stefan Rudnicki, even in translation, expertly captures the rhythm of the Yiddish voice.

Not to take anything away from Isaac Bashevis Singer, but it's a shame that his older brother has been overlooked. He died prematurely of a heart attack in 1944, having published only a handful of works. His now more famous brother started writing in earnest after his death. I.B Singer's own epic, The Family Moskat, examines the same era in Jewish history, but was written after the Holocaust and is therefore viewed through that lens.


.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Wonderful Novel and Outstanding Performance!

I read I.J. Singer’s “The Brothers Ashkenazi” for the first time more than twenty-years ago and was blown away.

Singer’s descriptions indolence and brutality among the wealthy, hypocrisy and madness among the pious, fanaticism bordering on madness among political radicals, brutality and bigotry among the poor and struggling, and filth and opulence in Lodz from the fin de siècle through the years immediately after the Great War and Poland’s Independence are evocative in the extreme.

The characters in this novel are often simultaneously deeply sympathetic and maddeningly vicious at the same time—and it all feels so relatable and real. Few are truly reprehensible even as they are doing reprehensible deeds, and those motivated by faith (either religious or worldly) to live without compromise on behalf of justice neglect and scorn many of those who care the most for them. The viscera of Lodz itself comes to life through Singer’s ability to evoke the sights, smells, sounds and feelings of the city through a period of great upheaval and tremendous suffering.

The brilliance of this book should have earned it a readership as wide as any of the other great novels of twentieth century. That brilliance is accentuated by the outstanding narration of Stefan Rudnicki who brings the characters to life with great skill and facility. I hope this is the first of many audio books by I.J. Singer and Stefan Rudnicki. “The Family Carnovsky,” and “Yoshe Kalb” would be my candidates for the next two works to record.

Cannot recommend this highly enough.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great book from a great author

Great book from a great author! The book describes a lost world. It is a tribute to the jewish life in Eastern Europe, that was destroyed by the evil.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Tolstoy, watch out!

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

How is it that I.J. Singer is not read widely? His story-telling skills are on a par with Tolstoy. His characters are rich and varied just as in War and Peace and cover as much war, geography (Poland and Russia), labor relations, class struggle, and individual turmoil.

What did you like best about this story?

Reading how traditional societies morph into secular culture and revolutionary movements.

Have you listened to any of Stefan Rudnicki’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

N/A

If you could take any character from The Brothers Ashkenazi out to dinner, who would it be and why?

Nissan. He's the son of an ultra-orthodox Jewish rabbi, but he is not religious. Instead, his creed is Marxism. He's so pure in his beliefs and clearly the hero of this multi-layered novel.

Any additional comments?

I wish more of Singer's books were available on audio.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!