Best of the series, can't wait for more

This is the third installment in a series by Bruce DeSilva about a newspaper reporter and his cast of friends, peers, co-workers, and enemies.
It's a fun series. I was first drawn to it in the very first book because not everything wrapped up with a neat little bow. Things are messy, which keeps it really interesting.

In "Providence Rag," the "bad guy" is colorful and surprising and not-cookie-cutter and the story spans three decades which is also a great twist. All of the characters that you've gotten to know from the first two books are back, so DeSilva weaves the expected and unexpected together in a great way.

You don't have to have read the first two books to enjoy this one. He catches the reader up in a smooth way, without repeating too much from previous books. But you'll have a deeper understanding of the characters and relationships if you start from the beginning.

I only gave it 4 stars because it's still not to the level of a Lee Child, or Tom Clancy, or even Owen Laukkanen. The depth of the characters can still be improved. I wanted to know a lot more about the blond lawyer, and the character "Mason" also known as "Yes Dad" could be explored better and deeper. There were a couple chunks of this story that were slow, but overall it had a great pace. It's really a big improvement from the first book, which I liked enough to keep going.

The narrator, Woodman, is good. He changed accents a couple times which was weird, but overall he does a good job.

I recommend this book and am excited for the next one.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A place to remember

Loved the story - but the sense of place and the social structure of Little Rhody are what make deSilvas' books so great.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Soooo Scary

This is THE most scary story I have listened to. DeSilva kept the tension high throughout the book, only letting it down when the listener couldn''t bear another moment of it. The pacing of the story is very good. Nary a dull moment to be heard. And the reader, well, if there is a better one around, I haven't heard him/her. After listening to dozens of Audible Books by other readers, eff Woodman has become my reader of choice. I will definitely be looking for more of his books. His reading was flawless. He had perfect diction, perfect timing, perfect gender voice imitation, perfect pitch, perfect Everything. He didn't miss a beat anywhere in the telling of this tale. His reading was absolutely masterful. Who ever selected Woodman to do the reading definitely chose the best person for the job.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Listened straight through

What did you love best about Providence Rag?

I enjoyed the tightly knit plot of what happened when Kwami Diggs brutally murdered 2 women and 3 little girls before he was 16. Liam Mulligan, an investigative reporter for the Providence, Rhode Island, newspaper, identified him as the murderer and provided vital testimony to put him in jail, hopefully for life. However an antiquated R.I. law allowed Kwami who was charged as a minor, to be released once he reached the age of 21. Because of his heinous crimes and the glee he expressed in the original confession tape, the judicial system had been keeping him locked up by faking charges against him to keep him in jail. By this time, Kwami has been locked up for 18 years and his mother has hired a new lawyer to get him set free because she believes Kwami was framed for these horrible crimes. Mulligan's co-worker, Edward Mason, begins to dig into the charges that Kwami has been kept locked up for the previous 12 years due to trumped up charges and is horrified at the way the justice system has been perverted to keep this boy in prison-even though no one wants to release Kwami on the public.

Did the plot keep you on the edge of your seat? How?

This story is based on a real life incident and arrived at a satisfactory conclusion even though Kwami did get released from prison in the story. One wonders how things turned out in the real life situation. The entire book kept me wondering what was going to happen next. I was sorry to reach the end.

What about Jeff Woodman’s performance did you like?

He did the voices of the various characters very well. Every person had his/her own voice. He brought Kwami Diggs' aging mother alive so well I could almost see her standing in front of me-a slim aging black woman who has grieved and cried over her son for many years and who has desperately believed him innocent of all charges right up until she is finally forced to watch the tape of Kwami's confession when he was arrested at the age of 15 and forced to face his lies.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

I found the opening chapters to be graphic enough that i almost quit listening to it. i continued because i was drawn into the story very quickly.i found the basic premise of this book, that a psychopathic monster can be released into the community simply because he grew up to be terrifying. But even more terrifying is the idea that a prisoner who is legally entitled to be set free can be shanghaied into staying in prison by perjurous guards.

Any additional comments?

Legislators need to pay attention to the laws they make so this does not happen again!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good... But

Starts out a 5... Ends up a 4. Got a little off course and the ending seemed rushed.

However... Can anyone tell me why is it every author seems incapable of NOT sharing, even indirectly, their political leanings?? Do they not understand that most of us just do not care?? Liberals will rate this a 5.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Where is Book 4?! Can't WAIT!!!

The previous two books were excellent but somehow, this one was even better! Apparently Bruce DeSilva is getting better and better and Liam Mulligan and the people around him - and the stories they're involved in - are more and more interesting. Keep writing! THANK YOU for a great story. The narrator is perfect for these books. Thankful they've kept Jeff Woodman for all the books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Really lukewarm. Tepid, in fact.

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

No. There are so many other police procedurals, murder mysteries, detective stories, etc. that are so much better than this. The first two books in this series are way better than this.

Would you be willing to try another book from Bruce DeSilva? Why or why not?

Probably not. I think he has gone to this well enough times. Although of course I know nothing about the author's life, but the book really sounds autobiographical to me. There is an awful lot of talk and almost no action. The life of a police reporter on the crime beat has no real dramatic value.

Did the narration match the pace of the story?

Yes. Both are slow. The narrator does what sounds to me like a valid Rhode Island accent (although I am no authority on this). However, what little plot there is is drowned by detail that may have journalistic value but is a poor cousin of good fiction. Mr. De Silva should read a little Thomas Perry. Then, he should go back to being a journalist.

Did Providence Rag inspire you to do anything?

Absolutely nothing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

Tremendous Series, great narration.

Mulligan is a great reporter working in a dying industry. The mystery is great, but it's the cast that makes this series a winner.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Good Story Telling

I liked the story. The author loved to throw in brand names of most everything that I didn't feel necessary. I live in the area so it's nice to have some history and back story about the area. Will definitely pick up more by Bruce DeSilva in the future

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Third Book in a Terrific Series - Love Them All

The author and narrator of this series have done a fabulous job of creating a wonderful series featuring journalists and cops and criminals. Read them in order (1- Rogue Island, 2-Cliff Walk, then 3-Providence Rag.) Mulligan is a lovable, flawed reporter for the Providence RI newspaper, which by the way, is on life support as are most newspapers these days. The story is VERY contemporary, citing everything from Obama Care to the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.
Each story is unique and different enough to grab your attention and engage your brain in solving the various conundrums the characters face. Political mud, mob crime, serial murders, and the ethics of modern day journalists are central to the stories and make for very good listening!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful