We know it’s name now

The history of pandemics should be required for every high school student. This is an opportunity to integrate all coursework with real world problems. As a data science teacher for 30 years trying to bring Computer science education to all I know our future depends on giving our youth digital research tools - like “R” and a motivator to do something for others.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

good story, narration...not so much

the story was good, interesting. But the pronunciation of many of the words was difficult to listen to. also, the usage of "cholera vibrio" instead of "vibrio cholera" was really bothering me. the tone was good, made it more dramatic, I just couldn't stand all the mispronounciations.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

I usually don’t write reviews but wow!!

This is one of the best audio books I have heard in a long time!

The author is very clear and concise. She is easy to follow along to and stays to the facts. It is very enlightening in times like these!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fascinating and well written

I loved this book. It is well written, and complex topics are well explained for people who don't have a scientific background. I found the content fascinating and pertinent. The author did a thorough job of explaining the scientific, historical, evolutionary, and social aspects of cholera pandemics and the ramifications for future pandemics. She obviously did her research. I enjoyed the reader because her reading style did not distract me from the content, as some audio book readers do.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

new infotmation

The author has done good research, and layed out the material in a very logical, easy to follow form. I've read a number of books on similar topics, but this one definitely had new and interesting material for me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Interesting but not engaging

I find predators fascinating. Especially those predators that eat us from the inside, which is the topic of this book. I had hoped for more of what I got when I read David Quammen’s excellent book “Spillover” which focuses on microorganisms that jump from one species to humans. Such zoonoses tend to be especially difficult to eradicate because even if we manage to eliminate the disease in humans, it can jump over again from the reservoir. This book, unfortunately, did not reach the same level as Spillover, far from it actually. It was informative, but I never felt very excited when I picked up the book. It was more like listening to a mediocre university teacher. It felt a bit flat and encyclopedic, and it lacked a clear narrative.

The book describes some past and present pandemics, including HIV, SARS, Ebola and influenza. However, the author keeps returning to is Cholera. Why is Cholera interesting you may ask? Because it is a pandemic that has gone endemic, meaning it is constantly present in the human population and health organisations have, to some extent, stopped trying to eradicate it. This is despite the fact that, without medication (clean water), there is a 50/50 chance of being killed by Cholera. This puts Cholera on par with Ebola. Indeed, the message that the author tries to convey is that when we think of future pandemics we should think Cholera, not Ebola. The big killers in the world today are the pandemics that go “under the radar” - like Cholera but also influenza. I think that this was a valid and important point, and there is already one clear candidate for what might be the future Cholera, namely MRSA (bacteria that are resistant to antibiotics).

So all in all, there is definitively some interesting information in this book, and it does reach some interesting conclusions. But unfortunately, the book is not well organized, and the writing is not very engaging. Simply put, there are better alternatives.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

12 people found this helpful

Very interesting and informative

I binge-listened to this book, because I couldn't stop. I had heard the author interviewed on NPR and was interested. The story is very informative, but entertaining.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

You will probably enjoy "Spillover" more

I am in the middle of reading Spillover and am enjoying it much more than this book. Pandemic is more current for certain, but David Quammen, the Author of Spillover, is by far more scientifically literate. Shah spends an awful lot of time focused on paradigm shifts in science. She even seems to have a really good grasp of Thomas Kuhn's arguments; and yet, she failed to realize the science she researched for this book has been pushed out by the very methods Kuhn elucidated in book, in fact the very methods she, herself, wrote about in this very book. She seems to lack critical thinking skills when it comes to psychology studies, never questioning the methods. If someone said it was true, she seemed to not only accept it, despite glaring flaws in the methods for those studies, but used the bad studies to argue her opinion. The old way of viewing evolution, the selfish gene as driver of all evolution, is on its way out the door. Yet, she clings tightly to that paradigm. She is enamored with the good genes/sexy sons hypothesis, selfish gene dogma, David Buss style evolutionary psych (which amounts to "just-so-stories). Her lack of adopting a progressive paradigm, considering her progressive subject matter was disappointing at best. I also didn't relate to her personal experience with the virus she and her son share. That detracted from the story for me.

Even with the negatives, the subject matter is trilling. What she lacks in scientific understanding, she really makes up for with her history of various viruses. Absolutely fantastic.

If you are only going to read one book about pandemics, let it be Spillover. But, if you are willing to read more than one book, because of the history she provides, this is definitely worthwhile.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

15 people found this helpful

Excellent book on intro to public health

Author provides wonderful insight to the pathogens around us. What tasks can create the perfect storm for disease transmission covered here!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Informative and Interesting

This book is good for understanding outbreaks through the eyes of those working in that field. Some history, such as cholera outbreaks, are also included.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!