Electric Detective
An Eddie Evers Mystery, Book 1
Failed to add items
Add to Cart failed.
Add to Wish List failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Get 2 free audiobooks during trial.
Buy for $19.95
No default payment method selected.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
-
Narrated by:
-
Christopher Graybill
-
By:
-
E. E. King
About this listen
Humphrey Bogart meets The Man in the High Castle.
Eddie Evers was at the top of his game, working for the FBI, tracking missing children and the scum who took them. But after his wife and child are killed in a car crash, he becomes a hard-drinking PI. While in pursuit of a phantom criminal, he is hit by lightning.The bolt super-charges the biophotons in his brain, enabling him to see into other dimensions.
©2018 Elizabeth E King (P)2018 Elizabeth E KingListeners also enjoyed...
-
The Smuggler of Souls
- A Dark Fantasy Novel
- By: Nicholas Carey
- Narrated by: Christopher Graybill
- Length: 4 hrs and 27 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
God has fallen and the Devil is dead. Heaven, once paradise, now lies crumbling, ruinous and infested. It is a vile nest for an ancient evil that has its sights set on humanity. Only Death, and the peculiar band of souls that he has managed to smuggle to safety, are left to resist this threat. Can a marine commander, a samurai, a thief, and an axe-wielding highland warrior succeed where both God and Lucifer failed? Can Death finally find redemption for the most ancient of all sins?
-
-
The smuggler of souls
- By Deedra on 08-19-21
By: Nicholas Carey
-
First Deadly Conspiracy - Box Set
- McRyan Mystery Series, Books 1-3
- By: Roger Stelljes
- Narrated by: Johnny Peppers
- Length: 26 hrs and 1 min
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Fans of mysteries, thrillers, and suspense will enjoy these fast-moving stories of murder, greed, and treason, the cast of colorful characters, and their setting in and around historic St. Paul, Minnesota. This bundle includes First Case, The St. Paul Conspiracy, and Deadly Stillwater.
-
-
3.5 stars OK Series
- By Lia on 09-04-17
By: Roger Stelljes
-
Alone
- By: Lisa Gardner
- Narrated by: Anna Fields
- Length: 10 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
As a sniper with the elite Massachusetts State Police SWAT Team, Bobby Dodge saved a woman and her young son by shooting her armed husband. But vicious rumors begin to circulate the next morning when Bobby loses his gun and his privileges. It turns out the dead man was the son of a prominent Boston judge and had accused his wife of poisoning their son.
-
-
I know I'm not Alone . . .
- By Sherry on 02-06-05
By: Lisa Gardner
-
The Amazing Adventures of Mr. Tinker
- A Time Travel Novel
- By: Paul Ibbetson
- Narrated by: Darren Stephens
- Length: 1 hr and 50 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Follow the amazing Mr. Tinker, an inventor who, while working for Nikola Tesla, discovers time travel. After nine of his time traveling devices, called chronoboxes, are stolen by criminal scientists, he must travel through time to retrieve the boxes and safeguard the future. With the help of his young assistant Jovan, both will risk their lives in this exciting time travel novel.
-
-
A nice short story that ends with a cliffhanger
- By GLENNO on 04-12-18
By: Paul Ibbetson
-
The Murderer's Son
- A Jackman and Evans Thriller
- By: Joy Ellis
- Narrated by: Richard Armitage
- Length: 9 hrs and 30 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Crimebusting duo DI Jackman and DS Evans are back, solving another crime that will make your skin crawl. Twenty years ago: a farmer and his wife are cut to pieces by a ruthless serial killer. Now: a woman is viciously stabbed to death in the upmarket kitchen of her beautiful house on the edge of the marshes. Then a man called Daniel Kinder walks into Saltern police station and confesses to the murder. But DI Rowan Jackman and DS Marie Evans of the Fenland Constabulary soon discover that there is a lot more to Daniel than meets the eye.
-
-
Audible ruined this one for me.
- By Julie on 12-29-18
By: Joy Ellis
-
Unofficial Detective: The Mage Apprentice
- Half-Wizard Thordric, Book 1
- By: Kathryn Wells
- Narrated by: Morgan Keller
- Length: 4 hrs and 40 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
For his whole life, Thordric has been told that his magic is dangerous, and that he must never use it. All over Dinia, half-wizards are treated the same, their magic labelled as dangerous and uncontrollable. But when High Wizard Kalljard dies under mysterious circumstances, it falls to young Thordric to solve the case. The only trouble? The deed was done by magic, and though Thordric is a half-wizard, he has never fully used his powers. To prove himself right and find the person responsible, Thordric has to learn how to control his own powers.
-
-
Simple but Engaging
- By David Haynes on 09-27-19
By: Kathryn Wells
-
The Smuggler of Souls
- A Dark Fantasy Novel
- By: Nicholas Carey
- Narrated by: Christopher Graybill
- Length: 4 hrs and 27 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
God has fallen and the Devil is dead. Heaven, once paradise, now lies crumbling, ruinous and infested. It is a vile nest for an ancient evil that has its sights set on humanity. Only Death, and the peculiar band of souls that he has managed to smuggle to safety, are left to resist this threat. Can a marine commander, a samurai, a thief, and an axe-wielding highland warrior succeed where both God and Lucifer failed? Can Death finally find redemption for the most ancient of all sins?
-
-
The smuggler of souls
- By Deedra on 08-19-21
By: Nicholas Carey
-
First Deadly Conspiracy - Box Set
- McRyan Mystery Series, Books 1-3
- By: Roger Stelljes
- Narrated by: Johnny Peppers
- Length: 26 hrs and 1 min
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Fans of mysteries, thrillers, and suspense will enjoy these fast-moving stories of murder, greed, and treason, the cast of colorful characters, and their setting in and around historic St. Paul, Minnesota. This bundle includes First Case, The St. Paul Conspiracy, and Deadly Stillwater.
-
-
3.5 stars OK Series
- By Lia on 09-04-17
By: Roger Stelljes
-
Alone
- By: Lisa Gardner
- Narrated by: Anna Fields
- Length: 10 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
As a sniper with the elite Massachusetts State Police SWAT Team, Bobby Dodge saved a woman and her young son by shooting her armed husband. But vicious rumors begin to circulate the next morning when Bobby loses his gun and his privileges. It turns out the dead man was the son of a prominent Boston judge and had accused his wife of poisoning their son.
-
-
I know I'm not Alone . . .
- By Sherry on 02-06-05
By: Lisa Gardner
-
The Amazing Adventures of Mr. Tinker
- A Time Travel Novel
- By: Paul Ibbetson
- Narrated by: Darren Stephens
- Length: 1 hr and 50 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Follow the amazing Mr. Tinker, an inventor who, while working for Nikola Tesla, discovers time travel. After nine of his time traveling devices, called chronoboxes, are stolen by criminal scientists, he must travel through time to retrieve the boxes and safeguard the future. With the help of his young assistant Jovan, both will risk their lives in this exciting time travel novel.
-
-
A nice short story that ends with a cliffhanger
- By GLENNO on 04-12-18
By: Paul Ibbetson
-
The Murderer's Son
- A Jackman and Evans Thriller
- By: Joy Ellis
- Narrated by: Richard Armitage
- Length: 9 hrs and 30 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Crimebusting duo DI Jackman and DS Evans are back, solving another crime that will make your skin crawl. Twenty years ago: a farmer and his wife are cut to pieces by a ruthless serial killer. Now: a woman is viciously stabbed to death in the upmarket kitchen of her beautiful house on the edge of the marshes. Then a man called Daniel Kinder walks into Saltern police station and confesses to the murder. But DI Rowan Jackman and DS Marie Evans of the Fenland Constabulary soon discover that there is a lot more to Daniel than meets the eye.
-
-
Audible ruined this one for me.
- By Julie on 12-29-18
By: Joy Ellis
-
Unofficial Detective: The Mage Apprentice
- Half-Wizard Thordric, Book 1
- By: Kathryn Wells
- Narrated by: Morgan Keller
- Length: 4 hrs and 40 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
For his whole life, Thordric has been told that his magic is dangerous, and that he must never use it. All over Dinia, half-wizards are treated the same, their magic labelled as dangerous and uncontrollable. But when High Wizard Kalljard dies under mysterious circumstances, it falls to young Thordric to solve the case. The only trouble? The deed was done by magic, and though Thordric is a half-wizard, he has never fully used his powers. To prove himself right and find the person responsible, Thordric has to learn how to control his own powers.
-
-
Simple but Engaging
- By David Haynes on 09-27-19
By: Kathryn Wells
-
Between Jobs
- City Between Series, Book 1
- By: W.R. Gingell
- Narrated by: Zehra Jane Naqvi
- Length: 7 hrs and 43 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When you get up in the morning, the last thing you expect to see is a murdered guy hanging outside your window. Things like that tend to draw the attention of the local police, and when you're squatting in your parents' old house until you can afford to buy it, another thing you can't afford is the attention of the cops. Oh yeah. Hi. My name is Pet. It's not my real name, but it's the only one you're getting.
-
-
You Won't Regret Listening to it!
- By Amazon Customer on 03-18-19
By: W.R. Gingell
-
The 7 She Saw
- Blake Wilder FBI Mystery Thriller, Book 1
- By: Elle Gray
- Narrated by: Brittany Goodwin
- Length: 7 hrs and 10 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Blake Wilder is plagued with nightmares from her dark and twisted past. Fourteen years ago, her entire family was taken from her. Her parents murdered and her sister taken. At the age of 22, Blake joined the FBI in hopes of one day discovering the truth behind the mysteries of her own past.
-
-
So good I want to read the whole series :)
- By Mending_Echoes on 09-05-21
By: Elle Gray
-
Aurora Rising
- The Aurora Cycle, Book 1
- By: Amie Kaufman, Jay Kristoff
- Narrated by: Kim Mai Guest, Johnathan McClain, Candice Moll, and others
- Length: 14 hrs and 4 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The year is 2380, and the graduating cadets of Aurora Academy are being assigned their first missions. Star pupil Tyler Jones is ready to recruit the squad of his dreams, but his own boneheaded heroism sees him stuck with the dregs nobody else in the academy would touch....
-
-
Excellent story, but a little overly emotive
- By Zach on 05-15-19
By: Amie Kaufman, and others
-
Storm Front
- The Dresden Files, Book 1
- By: Jim Butcher
- Narrated by: James Marsters
- Length: 8 hrs and 1 min
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
A call from a distraught wife, and another from Lt. Murphy of the Chicago PD Special Investigation Unit makes Harry believe things are looking up, but they are about to get worse, much worse. Someone is harnessing immense supernatural forces to commit a series of grisly murders. Someone has violated the first law of magic: Thou Shalt Not Kill. Tracking that someone takes Harry into the dangerous underbelly of Chicago, from mobsters to vampires....
-
-
Excellent Story, Distracting Sound Engineering
- By Tom on 05-20-10
By: Jim Butcher
-
Soul Fraud
- By: Andrew Givler
- Narrated by: Michael Mola
- Length: 10 hrs and 39 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Matt has a terrible life. Seriously—it's awful. It is so bad that Dan the Demon is shocked when Matt turns down his infernal offer: 10 years of a blissful life in exchange for his soul. But Dan is a salesman behind on his quota and his demonic managers are running out of patience. He forges Matt's signature on the dotted line, stealing his soul and thrusting him into a supernatural world he never knew existed. Matt must learn to navigate the hidden society of demons, faeries, demigods, and worse.
-
-
Great Story
- By Brad Frederick on 07-23-22
By: Andrew Givler
-
Lucifer Reborn
- Lucifer Reborn, Book 1
- By: Dante King
- Narrated by: Lewis Alexander, Rozelyn Rader
- Length: 10 hrs and 11 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The devil paid me a visit and said I was going to one day rule his demonic kingdom. The catch: I have to attend the Infernal Academy, located in none other than Hell itself. Thankfully, I won’t be doing it alone. I’m going to surround myself with powerful demonesses (and maybe an angel or two as well).
-
-
Great Story Pathetically Dumb MC
- By Avid Fantasy Reader on 10-01-21
By: Dante King
-
The Dispatcher
- By: John Scalzi
- Narrated by: Zachary Quinto
- Length: 2 hrs and 18 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Zachary Quinto - best known for his role as the Nimoy-approved Spock in the recent Star Trek reboot and the menacing, power-stealing serial killer, Sylar, in Heroes - brings his well-earned sci-fi credentials and simmering intensity to this audio-exclusive novella from master storyteller John Scalzi. One day, not long from now, it becomes almost impossible to murder anyone - 999 times out of a thousand, anyone who is intentionally killed comes back. How? We don't know.
-
-
IT'S HARD TO GET MYSTICAL ABOUT YOUR JOB
- By Jim "The Impatient" on 10-05-16
By: John Scalzi
-
Junkyard Cats
- Shining Smith, Book 1
- By: Faith Hunter
- Narrated by: Khristine Hvam
- Length: 5 hrs and 2 mins
- Original Recording
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
After the Final War, after the appearance of the Bug aliens and their enforced peace, Shining Smith is still alive, still doing business from the old scrapyard bequeathed to her by her father. But Shining is now something more than human. And the scrapyard is no longer just a scrapyard, but a place full of secrets. This life she has built, while empty, is predictable and safe. Until the only friend left from her previous life shows up, dead, in the back of a scrapped Tesla warplane. Clutched in her cold fingers is a note to Shining - warning her of a coming attack.
-
-
Would be a great story, if most of it wasn't missi
- By Amazon Customer on 01-11-20
By: Faith Hunter
-
14
- By: Peter Clines
- Narrated by: Ray Porter
- Length: 12 hrs and 34 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
There are some odd things about Nate’s new apartment. Of course, he has other things on his mind. He hates his job. He has no money in the bank. No girlfriend. No plans for the future. So while his new home isn’t perfect, it’s livable. The rent is low, the property managers are friendly, and the odd little mysteries don’t nag at him too much. At least, not until he meets Mandy, his neighbor across the hall, and notices something unusual about her apartment. And Xela’s apartment. And Tim’s. And Veek’s.
-
-
Super solid listen!!
- By Magpie on 06-24-12
By: Peter Clines
-
Kill Joy
- A Good Girl's Guide to Murder Novella
- By: Holly Jackson
- Narrated by: Bailey Carr, Raymond J. Lee, Bruce Mann
- Length: 2 hrs and 37 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Pip is not in the mood for her friend’s murder mystery party. Especially one that involves 1920’s fancy dress and pretending that their town is an island called Joy. But when the game begins, Pip finds herself drawn into the make-believe world of intrigue, deception and murder. But as Pip plays detective, teasing out the identity of the killer clue-by-clue, the murder of the fictional Reginald Remy isn’t the only case on her mind …
-
-
Short and sweet
- By Tressa Mower on 04-28-23
By: Holly Jackson
-
Before She Disappeared
- A Novel (A Frankie Elkin Novel, Book 1)
- By: Lisa Gardner
- Narrated by: Hillary Huber
- Length: 12 hrs and 7 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Frankie Elkin is an average middle-aged woman, a recovering alcoholic with more regrets than belongings. But she spends her life doing what no one else will - searching for missing people the world has stopped looking for. When the police have given up, when the public no longer remembers, when the media has never paid attention, Frankie starts looking. A new case brings her to Mattapan, a Boston neighborhood with a rough reputation. She is searching for Angelique Badeau, a Haitian teenager who vanished from her high school months earlier.
-
-
One of my favorite authors...
- By shelley on 01-20-21
By: Lisa Gardner
-
The Maid's Diary
- A Novel
- By: Loreth Anne White
- Narrated by: Jane Oppenheimer
- Length: 12 hrs and 10 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Kit Darling is a maid with a snooping problem. She’s the “invisible girl,” compelled to poke into her wealthy clients’ closely guarded lives. It’s a harmless hobby until Kit sees something she can’t unsee in the home of her brand-new clients: a secret so dark it could destroy the privileged couple expecting their first child. This makes Kit dangerous to the couple. In turn, it makes the couple—who might kill to keep their secret—dangerous to Kit.
-
-
Dark, powerful, twisty thriller
- By MA Reviewer on 03-04-23
What listeners say about Electric Detective
Average customer ratingsReviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- John G. Stone
- 02-13-20
Fun 40s gumshoe story ends abruptly
Interesting twist on a campy 40s detective story with lots of over-the-top dialogue. Fun twist was the effect lighting had on Eddie. Obviously going to be more stories in the series but this ending was too abrupt.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Cindy
- 01-16-20
Science Class
The first half of this story was somewhat confusing for me, not sure where it was going. The second half finally pulled it all together. I felt I was sitting in a science classroom listening to a teacher combine the lesson with a story. In the end, I felt this could become a good series if there was more story less homework.
On the other hand, this narrator was awesome. At one point in the story that dealt with hypnosis, his voice almost had me under. Great job!
This audio was given to me free and I voluntarily gave this review.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Bryan Spencer
- 01-28-20
LSD it’s organic
A fun sci-fi mystery. Very enjoyable and great narration.
This book was provided free for review, however, the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Jacob P
- 01-16-20
Good, Solid Modern-day Sci-Fi Detective Noir
E. E. King has written a classic noir detective story in the modern-day, with an intriguing sci-fi twist. Eddie's abilities, as they develop and he gains a better understanding of them, are different and pretty original. There are plenty of twists and turns along the way, and emotional hooks that make you feel for the situations Eddie is forced to confront. The performance is solid and really helps with getting inside Eddie's head. The only downside that felt completely unnecessary to me was the occasional harshly derogatory comments/thoughts by Eddie about religion in general (especially Christianity and Mormonism) and Texas/Texans, many of which I found highly ignorant of the beliefs and knowledge base of the average members of those religions I have met and people I know who tend more conservative (including those in Texas). While not a Phillip K. Dick level of making you think about the implications of new technology or worldview (due to the 'right' conclusions being very clearly laid out), it is reminiscent of the tone of many of Dick's works. Overall I would recommend to anyone who is a fan of Phillip K Dick or a good noir detective story. Good as an introduction to a series but also works well as a stand-alone story.
Disclaimer: I was given this free review copy audiobook and have voluntarily left this review.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Katarina
- 01-26-20
Okay origin story
As origin stories of super heroes or otherwise 'specially gifted' people, this one is okay. It has a fun original premise, and a nice 'grumpy detective' tone. However it also suffers from a LOT of exposition, so much so it often seems like a wannebe school book of some sorts. Several characters explaining the plot to eachother, and it worsens toward the end, where the 'bad guy' actually takes quite some time to explain everything.
Also, the narrator does not help. I suspect the story would be better if I had simply read it; the narrator reads everything with the same intonation and that does not make for a suspenseful story. I didn't like the strange softer voice he chose for female characters, and that he sometimes mixes up with his male characters.
I have to admit that although I finished the book, I couldn't concentrate through all of it, finding my thoughts wandering to other things.
The author can write though, and has a very promising knack for witty banter.
Perhaps the sequel will be better.
This book was given to me for free at my request and I provided this review voluntarily.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- murphyfields
- 01-28-20
`Fun Story, Great Characters
This was kind of an odd story, but odd in a good way. I loved the characters, and especially the cat. The story captured my attention, and I would love to hear a little more of what happens to Eddie. Eddie is the typical smart-ass alcoholic detective, with an eye for the ladies and a real interesting perspective on the alcohol which he is consuming and which in turn is consuming him.
Christopher Graybill gives a great voice to Eddie, as well as the rest of the cast of characters.
I was given a free copy of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Laura
- 02-11-20
Too Many Information Dumps
I received this book for free. I am voluntarily posting this review and all opinions expressed herein are my own.
This is a film noir wanna be [think Humphrey Bogart in the Maltese Falcon]. What's interesting about this book is the MC is hit by lightning which creates a superpower of sorts. The MC is an alcoholic and frankly, not all that interesting. On top of that, there were so many information dumps through characters [plus the science part felt like I was in a classroom] that I felt my mind wandering. There is some witty banter, which I enjoyed. I thought I would love this but instead I found myself a little less than interested.
The narrator, Christopher Graybill, was really great. He was absolutely enjoyed his narration.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
3 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Amazon Customer
- 01-23-20
Fun Detective Noir
I got this as a free book in exchange for a review. I get a bunch from the Reddit audiobooks thread but most are pretty bad and I just don’t bother writing reviews.
I found this book surprisingly fun. It has a lot of Los Angeles atmosphere and it’s very detective noir with great lines every other minute. “Just as useful as a butter knife in a slaughter house”. “She didn’t need ice, she was cool enough without it.” I’m telling you, every other minute, writing is awesome witty.
If you love down on their luck, alcoholic detectives with witty dialogue, this book will be a keeper. There’s also a fantasy element to it. But I think that’s an excuse for the detective to see everything in black and white. If this book has a bad review, it’s because the listener was hoping for a fantasy book and found this instead. But if you are looking for detective noir, it’s more than solid and the narration is perfect.
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Jbudd
- 01-27-20
Noir Detective story with several twists
I thoroughly enjoyed E.E. King's story of Eddie Evers, the "Electric Detective". Narration by Christopher Graybill was spot on and competent. So, a Noir Detective story set in LA with a Quantum Twist. An embittered former police detective who specializes in missing children cases, Eddie Evers has had personal tragedy and PTSD from his past work. Yes the alcoholic Private eye is indeed a fiction trope - but Eddie Evers has unique abilities to perceive the past and the present and to read emotions - a result of being struck by lightning. There is a wealth of wit and metaphor and I found myself starting to like Eddie as the story continues. E. E. King knows how to turn a phrase. I hope to see more of this complex character in the future.
Disclaimer:"I was given this free review copy audiobook at my request and have voluntarily left this review."
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Sidney G Fooshee
- 01-25-20
Interesting Take on the Noir Detective
Requested a free code in exchange for an honest review.
The narration is fantastic, perfect for this genre!
A detective is struck by lightning and gains special powers. It is an interesting premise and I enjoyed seeing how the story unfolded. I would like to listen to more books in the series!
If you found this review helpful, please indicate so. Thank You!
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
You voted on this review!
You reported this review!