A land Divided

it is so True. Never Trust an English Man. Napoleon Ryan is so talented and Fantastic, That his beautiful narration made the Story exciting and engaging.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great Way to Breathe Life into History

I look forward to the sequel - loved listening to the accents and pronunciations. Marvelous

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Entertaining historical fiction

This book was a pleasant surprise. It was a clear and informing historical narrative which took me to wind-swept Wales. Why worry about Game of Thrones when our own history has had plenty of intrigue, love and war?

While it was possible to get to know the characters from their actions and speech, I would have liked to delve deeper into them and explore them more. This wish is recurrent in the genre, and not only in this particular book.

I enjoyed the narrator, and even his feminine voices.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Narrators and foreign language pronunciations

What made the experience of listening to A Land Divided the most enjoyable?

I love the story and the reader's voice is resonant and skilled at changing voices for different characters. He even does female voices very well, avoiding the disagreeable falsetto many male readers adopt.

What did you like best about this story?

Well, I love Welsh history and this story is one covers a period with which until now I was unfamiliar. And I like that the author creates strong female characters.

What about Napoleon Ryan’s performance did you like?

I have listened to many books narrated by NR. I love everything about his voice. But in this book he makes a few unpardonable errors. Before reading a book with foreign words, he should either research correct pronunciation of places and names or be coached by a native speaker. Thank goodness there were not too many instances of words with the double L sound because he butchered it, pronouncing it with a kl sound. And the name Gruffydd is badly mispronounced. He pronounces the first syllable "gruff" where it should be like griff (as in griffin. Other than that I adore NR as a narrator. I have looked for books he narrated, just to hear his voice. But this time I often cringed.

If you could rename A Land Divided, what would you call it?

Game of Thrones

Any additional comments?

I think the penultimate question is irrelevant. Why would you want us to rename it?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A very entertaining story of Welsh history.

Knowing very little of medieval Welsh history and it's brief nationhood, I found Ashman's tale to be riveting for fans of historical fiction. Mr. Ryan's performance was outstanding and made the audible version come to life. Highly recommended for history buffs looking for a new era to read about.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Good Listen.

At first I didn't care for the narrator and didnt think Id care for the writing style .But it didnt take long and I was adjusted to the narrators voice and accents . He did a very good job with all the voices . The story is well told and enjoyable . I will listen to the whole series .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

love the storyline

absolutely love it. thre story line is awesome & it is still a great book

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

good story, terrible narration

I was very interested in the subject matter of this book. however, the narrator read as if he were a parent doing over the top voices for a young child. despite the lack of humor in the subject material, the narrator sounded ironic and even mocking. I really want to know what happens next so I will probably get the next two books, but I'm not looking forward to more of this narration.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Game of Thrones knockoff

Literally cut and paste GoT characters and use different names. They even have a red wedding.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Poorly written - Aweful dialog

I listened to the whole thing just in case it got better, but it didn't. The dialog is simplistic and doesn't even remotely represent anything even close to what natural dialog would be in those situations.

Additionally the author doesn't have a good grasp of leadership or warfare. I would advise him to make a study of both topics. The leaders and warriors didn't talk or behave as leaders and warriors would. I can't speak to how things happened at that time in history, but I do have intimate knowledge of warfare and leading combat troops. Nothing in the story even came close to representing any real leadership style, nor any closer to expressing the motivation, or sentiments of warriors. It was all quite ridiculous and impossible to take seriously.. Many authors with no leadership or combat experience still are able to make things seem both plausible and real by researching both topics. The way we fight has changed, but combat leadership and war are still essentially the same. The traits that would make you a good warrior or leader then would still serve you now and vice versa. The aspects that have changed over the centuries are just technical.

I was really bummed out because from the description it seemed like a good story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful