Christmas isn’t all sugarplums and reindeer. Nick and Mike dive into the chilling tales of Krampus, the goat-demon, and Iceland’s Yule Cat, the fashion-policing feline. Spoiler: Both are terrifying.

Join Nick and special guest Rich, host of The Wampa Diaries, as they dive into the Amityville Horror—a story so full of creepy vibes and questionable decisions that it's basically a DIY guide to ruining your life in 28 days. From haunted houses and creepy priests to poltergeist-style slime and glowing pig demons, this episode covers all the supernatural drama you didn’t ask for but totally deserve. Buckle up for a deep dive into one of the most famous ghost stories in American history—because why not?

Nick, Adam, and Jack team up to tackle one of the most famous UFO abduction cases of all time—the story of Travis Walton. Known as the inspiration for the cult classic Fire in the Sky, Walton’s harrowing five-day disappearance in the Arizona wilderness left skeptics scratching their heads and believers nodding knowingly. Join us as we explore the eerie events of that November night in 1975, the aftermath, and the lingering mysteries. Was it an out-of-this-world encounter or an elaborate story? Grab your tinfoil hat—things are about to get weird.

Dive into the chilling tale of history’s most infamous “vampire,” Elizabeth Bathory, as Nick and Anya dissect the blood-soaked legend behind the countess who put Transylvania on the map for all the wrong reasons.

What do a bridge, a guy in a bunny costume, and some missing folks have in common? Northern Virginia’s creepiest urban legend. Nick and Anya unravel the strange (and slightly ridiculous) tale of the Bunny Man.

This week Nick and Anya team up with Dave Prescott from Cryptid Cocktail Party to dive into the legend of the Skinwalker, the Southwest’s favorite nightmare fuel. If you’ve ever wondered what lurks in the desert (hint: it’s not just coyotes), this episode’s got you covered. From shape-shifting witches with attitude problems to the notoriously creepy Skinwalker Ranch, we break down why your next road trip through Utah might come with an unwanted, uh...tour guide. Grab a drink and get ready to question every rustle in the bushes.

Join us and special guest Mike Caurso as we delve into one of New Orleans' most haunted legends—the LaLaurie Mansion. We’ll pull back the curtain on Madame Delphine LaLaurie’s chilling past, from her notorious deeds to the eerie hauntings that still plague her home today. With Mike’s take on the city’s supernatural pulse, we dig into the twisted tales and ghostly encounters that make this mansion one of the most unsettling spots in the French Quarte

Mount St. Helens erupted in 1980, but something far stranger than ash clouds emerged from the chaos—Batsquatch. Nick and Anya, joined by friend of the show Jake Clauson, dive deep into the legend of this cryptid: a winged creature with an ape-like body and glowing red eyes. With sightings dating back to the eruption, the Batsquatch has haunted the wilderness for decades. Could these encounters be real, or is it all just a product of volcanic paranoia? Join us as we sift through the ashes to uncover the truth behind this eerie creature.