In the vibrant heart of New Orleans' French Quarter, Helga presides over a quaint antique shop, her haven of mystical enchantment. As a witch with eyes that blaze silver when her powers surge, she is no stranger to the supernatural. Yet, she finds herself beleaguered by the mischievous company of three resident ghosts, who revel in her attention while she tends to her arcane business.

However, the real trouble begins when she stumbles upon a lifeless body, pierced through the heart with an arrow. As whispers of blame and suspicion circle around her, Helga wonders if the victim's resentful wife might be responsible, or if the arrow itself carries a deeper significance. Could it be the work of a rogue Cupid, or perhaps a malevolent force seeping into the ordinary world?

Bound by the unbreakable bond of witchcraft, Helga's coven stands by her side, ready to unravel the mystery. Comprised of her sister Gwen and an eccentric group of friends from the Shear Magic hair salon, they each possess unique skills and secrets. Yet, Helga can't shake the nagging doubt that one of them might be involved in the heinous act.

Enter Jacob, a sharp-witted detective and an old friend of Helga's from their school days. Although he lacks Helga's mystical abilities, his keen intuition and smoldering gaze are assets in their own right. Together, they must navigate a tangled web of deceit, love, and arcane forces to unveil the truth and clear Helga's name before it's too late.