The tragedy of hate and war.

It seems almost impossible, today, with all our easy access to learning and information, that a person had suffer and sacrifice so much for an education. The story is beautiful and so, so terribly sad. I was heartbroken at times, humiliated to be part of "the priviliged" and ashamed of our lack of true compassion. But also encouraged that somehow, somewhere redemption is still possible.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

A beautiful story

What did you love best about Caleb's Crossing?

I enjoyed Caleb's tale as told by Bethia Mayfield who in her own headstrong way set him up to receive the gifts of knowledge but at a significant cost.

What about Jennifer Ehle’s performance did you like?

Jennifer Ehle was excellent in this role.

Any additional comments?

Highly recommended.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Not memorable but good to fill in time

I have a love of Geraldine's books. This one however is not great. It lacks the depth and sincerity of previous offerings. I enjoyed it on a superficial level.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Caleb's Crossing a Challenge

As an avid book reader, this presentation convinced me that I would probably not have finished the written version. Ms Ehle's concise rendition put me right there in that time zone and I could visualise the characters. She glided over the intense scholarly references and Latin quotations, which I might have baulked at, with ease, so that combined with Ms Brooks's writing technique, I became totally immersed right to the end. How interesting that the one review I read was a total contradiction of this view.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 3 personas

A wonderful story beautifully written

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

This in an interesting window into the world of the pilgrims and the customs and beliefs of some of the American Indians

What did you like best about this story?

The way the customs and practices of two different cultures are examined
It made me think about some ideas I have long taken for granted.

What does Jennifer Ehle bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

She read this well

Who was the most memorable character of Caleb's Crossing and why?

Many of the characters are interesting, complex and believable.

Any additional comments?

The relationships between the characters was interesting

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Superb story and an exceptional presenter

I came to know Geraldine Brooks' works when I had an extended stay in hospital some years ago. I came to know her as a gifted author with a rare gift for bringing history to life. In that same time I have become an Audible fan. I love the overall quality of the presentations I have heard. I note that two of Geraldine's books still are not available in audio formats, I hope that will be rectified soon.

I was excited to see the new book. I had no inkling at the beginning of what poor Caleb was crossing. I became immersed in the characters particularly Bethenie. I was fascinated by the tales of a very new Harvard - how could anyone then have foreseen what was to become one of the pre-eminent universities in the world. Learning about schooling in a hard land, the place of women, the struggle of life in a hard land for which the characters were not always equipped.

Through the story written by Brooks and narrated with a fine sense of the place of people throughout - excellent.

Jennifer Ehle made this story for me. The timbre, the overall quality of her voice and her timing as interwoven stories developed and reached their quite appropriate end, made me sad to be coming to the end of this story. Geraldine Brooks used old English and manufactures native indian language from one or more tribes - if I read this I would stumble. Jennifer Ehle nails the language structures gracefully. These language twists and turns a a very fascinating part of the overall story. And I have since completing the book gone a read-up on the early history of a great university.

Enjoy this one!

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 2 personas

An insight into a previously unknown history

What made the experience of listening to Caleb's Crossing the most enjoyable?

This novel introduced a part of history that had been unknown to me prior to listening to this recording. I found it most interesting to hear of the beginnings of Indian education and the strict views of Christianity at that time in Northern America.

What other book might you compare Caleb's Crossing to and why?

This book is quite different to Geraldine Brooks previous novels. I do like her style of writing and that she researches the culture and historical periods in which she writes with great care. I cannot campare it with any other book as it is the first on this topic that I have come across.

Which character – as performed by Jennifer Ehle – was your favorite?

Bethea the main character is my favourite because of her kindness, compassion, intelligence and determination.

Who was the most memorable character of Caleb's Crossing and why?

Caleb is the most memorable character because of his tremendous transformation yet ability to understand both cultures.

Any additional comments?

I enjoyed this book very much.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

Disappointed

I don't know how to describe my disappointment with this book. It was so hard to understand the story line. The audio was DREADFUL. I love Jennifer Ehle, in so many roles she has played, however she just couldn't get into any of the characters she was reading. Her voice was so monotone, her pronounciation was appalling, the entire book was just awful. I have re-listened to it, in the hope that I was not interpreting it correctly. Alas, no better. Sorry Jennifer, but this was certainly not one of your better performances,

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona