In the charming town of Christmas, Florida, Clint Mayfield and Adriana Pampas are caught in the crossfire of a generations-old rivalry.

Clint, a former baseball player sidelined by an injury, is pulled into the family business by his well-meaning but hot-tempered brother, Bronco, who harbors no love for the Pampas family.

On the other side is Adriana Pampas, who has one goal: to end the rivalry between her family and the Mayfields by buying them out.

When Clint and Adriana meet for the first time, things get heated, but not all the sparks flying between them are from anger—some are undeniably romantic.

Their heated argument unexpectedly ends in a kiss, sparking a chain of events neither could have anticipated. Unable to get Clint out of her mind, Adriana devises a bold plan: they’ll fake a relationship.

She claims it’s to push their families toward peace, but in truth, she hopes that more time with him will extinguish her unwanted attraction. However, the ruse quickly spirals out of control when Adriana impulsively announces their engagement.

As they navigate family tensions, shocking revelations about their grandfathers' past, and a high-stakes polo match that could change everything, Clint and Adriana begin to realize their fake relationship might be turning into something real.

Can love truly blossom amidst deep-seated grudges and old rivalries, or are they doomed to repeat the past?

Unexpectedly In Love is a heartwarming romantic comedy about family, forgiveness, and finding love in the most unexpected places.