After the Roundup

An important piece of history and an impressive effort in translation and narration.

Joseph Weismann's ability to write from the perspective he had as a child trying to navigate unthinkable atrocities offers the listener an incredibly unique and human experience that can't be found in a textbook. The translation by Richard Kutner and narration by J Clark Allison gives every effort to ensure Weismann's story is done justice, and the end result is a quality piece of history that should be shared.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

A French accent applied to a holocaust experience

Most holocaust memoirs I've read center around Poland and Germany. This is a story about the experience in France. It's skillfully told through the eyes of a young boy, although the story is being described by a rather old man. The transition from events as they occurred, to observations of their effects on him toward the end of the book (as told by the grown up young boy) is subtle and well constructed.

The author describes his harrowing experiences, and episodes of sheer luck, and provides some insight into the thought processes going through his mind - as the boy seeing and experiencing profound, harrowing and terrifying events - and as a mature man looking back on the events of his life, and the impacts they've had on him.

Well paced and well narrated.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Up there with "Man's Search for Meaning"

I received a promo code & have chosen to leave my honest opinions of the book & narration.

Listening to After the Roundup: Escape and Survival in Hitler’s France by Joseph Weismann, narrated by J. Clark Allison was excellent. When I'd only listened to 2 chapters so far, I could tell it's going to be one of my new favorites. Weismann wrote it in his eighties. Written in first person beginning when he was 10 in France in 1941 is a compelling beginning. J. has done an excellent job as a narrator, conveying the youth of the characters without making them sound silly. The holocaust was a disturbing disgusting experience. This is the first time I've read or listened to a story about it from the perspective of a child. In some ways, it made me think of the movie "Life is Beautiful," even though in this case it most certainly was not. But taking a subject matter so painfully horrific & viewing it through the lens of childhood. I also appreciated that Mr Weismann didn't just cover the years of the war, but the aftermath & continued persecution and anti-semitism that still exists today.
This now ranks right up there with my favorite war books, including: Les Miserables by Victor Hugo, All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque, And There Was Light by Jacques Lusseyran, (I'm disappointed it's only available abridged on Audible. Maybe Mr. Allison or I could one day rectify that. He handles the French much better than I would), Mankind's Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl.

Trigger warning - Aside from the obvious trauma of the holocaust, there is also a description of an instance of sexual abuse.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

Narrator added a lot to this book

I really enjoyed this book. I especially like the narrators voice, it made the powerful content easier to listen to then many books I've heard on audible.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

Let not history repeat

The horror. The trauma felt by young innocent children being taken away from their parents. The trauma lasts into adulthood. PTSD is very real. The millions ofinnoce.my lives taken from this worldly my God . This must never ever happen ever again. On this earth.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Inspiring, horrific and shamefully true story

Another horrific and painfully true account of how insanely barbaric the Nazi's and their sympathizers were. My thanks to the author for deciding to share such a raw and painful story. It was especially emotional and chilling for me, because my own grandparents (and dad) migrated from Paris and to NY in 1940.

How is it possible that humans could have behaved that way less than a generation ago? I worry about the rising trend of nationalistic and self-serving political leaders. I find myself encouraging others to ingest Joseph Weismann’s tragic story and to then take any action within their own power to prevent anything like this from ever happening again.

This is a book that you don’t want to read, but you really must.

DISCLAIMER: I was given a review copy audiobook by the author, narrator, or publisher at my request and have voluntarily left this review.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Incredible

i admire the author for his strength and resilience. Listening to this audiobook is as if I am journeying him all those years. Thank you for sharing your story Mr. Weismann. (I got this free copy in return for my honest opinion.)

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

What a tragic story for one so young

Can’t believe Joseph survived after incredible odds against him. He was still just a child just wanting some kindness which was in short supply He was stoic and I can’t believe he could remember all this after so many years. The devastating thing I took from this story is how he totally cut GOD out of his life and in many respects became a repressed bitter old man whose goal was to find happiness in life as he stated many times but never achieved it

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona

Thoughtful Recollection

I received this audiobook in exchange for an honest review.

Sad but inspiring: "After the Roundup: Escape and Survival in Hitler’s France" takes a look back at one man's journey through one of the darkest times in human history. Joseph Weismann writes about growing up in France, witnessing German cruelty, escaping from captivity and living life as a fugitive. J. Clark Allison maintains the melancholic tone with his steady narration and convincing dialogue. After the roundup should be read by any aspiring historian or WWII aficionado.

Joseph Weismann is a Jewish boy living in France. During WWII, he witnesses the appalling cruelty that many Germans exercised upon the Jewish population. Along with 13,000 Jews, Joseph and his family is rounded up and shipped to the Vélodrome d'Hiver stadium by cattle car. Facing deplorable conditions, Joseph makes a friend and escapes his prison. What follows is a life lived in secret. He moves from shelter to shelter, and he lives in fear of re-capture. Joseph clearly shares his emotions, opinions and convictions. It's obvious that the events of WWII deeply affected the outcome of Joseph's life. Although the majority of this work focuses on WWII and its immediate outcome, Joseph does briefly delve into his post-war life. The book's only downside is its length, which is a brief five hours and 48 minutes. Nonetheless, it makes for a captivating examination of France and Jewish oppression during WWII.

J. Clark Allison narrates "After the Roundup". His tone is sad and despondent, which fits the mood that Joseph expresses in his writing. His accents and inflections are believable, and he smoothly transitions between voices. He gives a consistent, strong performance. His narration is a solid compliment to the narrative.

"After the Roundup" is a touching novel. It shares an image of a very disturbing time in history. It's also encouraging and hopeful: Andrew fought against his oppressors and escaped from captivity. He made a new life for himself, and he lived to tell his story. His bravery is truly inspiring. Allison never detracts from the narrative. He gives a believable, moving performance. This book is highly recommended to those looking for a unique perspective of life during WWII.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Triumph!

nonfiction, historical-places-events, historical, france, family, friendship

When he is eighty, Joseph is made to see the good it will do for others to hear about the horror his life became in France in 1942. Born in France in 1931 to parents who lived in France after leaving a neighboring country twenty years earlier, he and his family were condemned by the Vichy government and Hitler because they were Jews not born in France. Think about it. What if you were herded into unsanitary and foodless arenas because of your religion and the fact that you or your parents were born in Wisconsin instead of, say, Texas. The conditions were horrible, parents separated from children who didn't know where parents were or that they, too, would be shipped off to the camps. Obviously Joseph escaped and suffered in other ways even after liberation, and much of that is related as well. This biography is excellent and most of it is written from the perspective of that young person. What a monumental task!
Equally monumental was the task faced by translator Richard Kutner in transforming the original French, complete with idioms from sixty years ago!
And don't forget how well J Clark Allison audio interpreted the writing without getting overly dramatic or doom and gloom. Fantastic!
I won the audio in a giveaway.
These things happened. Never Forget.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña