William

TERRIBLE BOOK WITH FAIR NARRATION (A SUR[RISE)

Revisado: 06-15-24

This takes place in the weeks leading up to DS9 Episode 1. Not much was revealed that we didnt already know from watching the DS9 series. Why was it bad? It just went on and on with annoying dialog and absolutely no action, drama or suspense until around chapter 30. It was dry, slow, and boring. To say nothing of the fact that the dialogue just got me annoyed. How.any true "Trecker" could rate this babble as good is a head scratcher. Kira was not like the kira of episode 1 at all. Garick had his witty moments, Dukot was Dukot but otherwise, Keiko's dialogue was poorly written and just made me fast forward when ever she was on. Oh, and the author need to research more the get the various characters of the Enterprises ranks correct.

Now the narration. Petkoff is generally a good narrator and he has Picard, Worf, Laforfge, and Crusher down pat. But his narration of characters outside of his wheelhouse was terrible, especially O'Brian, Keiko, and Kiera. He should have watched more old episodes to get it right. It was a difficult listen. If a book is really good, I will listen over and over. I listened to the "Pray" trilogy so many times I can recite the narration. Ditto for "Captian to Captian" trilogy. In the other universe, I listened to the "Thrawn Ascendency"trilogy probably 20 times as well as "Thrawn"/ This one, I sent back to the bin.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

BORING, BORING, BORING. Worst Trek book ever

Revisado: 07-26-21

Very difficult to finish. In a word - BORING. More of a who done it novel. Dont bother

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

First Impressions after 3 chapters

Revisado: 06-08-21

Seems like a good story however, Sullivan is no Robert Peckroff. He does a passable Kirk and McCoy but a poor vulcan, be it Sarek or Spock. Unfortunately the title is SAREK! His reading of the Sarek character is not terrible but still leaves much to be desired. Mark Thompson or Peckroff would have been better narrators.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Terrible Narration and Incomplete Story

Revisado: 03-23-21

Only the Quark character sounds like the actor. Sisko: terrible. Kira sounds like a man. Nog terrible. Jake: not bad. Most of the characters sounds the same. Morton is no Mark Thompson who is excellent or even Robert Petkoff who is very good. In addition, the story is shortened to the point that it jumps from one scene to the next. I read the book and this was just a poor job of converting a paperback to audible. So disappointed. Last, where are books 2 and 3??? What is the point of making a book 1 that ends abruptly when there is no book 2 or 3.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 2 personas

Totally Boring, Extremely Difficult to Listen to.

Revisado: 01-25-19

I found this to be terrible. On and on about nothing. If you are a girl, you may like it. If u are a neurotic teenager, you may like it. If you like the same idiotic storyline chapter after chapter, you may like it. I got so sick of listening to the father, the mother, I got to the point where i just had to keep fast forwarding until it was thankfully over.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña