AmazonCustomer
- 6
- opiniones
- 1
- voto útil
- 58
- calificaciones
-
The Victor of Gettysburg
- The Life and Career of General George Meade
- De: Charles River Editors
- Narrado por: Scott Clem
- Duración: 2 h y 37 m
- Versión completa
-
General
-
Narración:
-
Historia
Ironically, one of the generals who often escapes the attention of Civil War fans who compile the lists of best generals is the man who won the war's most famous battle, George G. Meade (1815-1872). In fact, Meade has become a perfect example of how the generals who did not self-promote themselves and write memoirs after the war had their reputations suffer in the ensuing decades.
-
-
Great understanding for a sadly overlooked America
- De Dennis Jennings en 07-05-22
- The Victor of Gettysburg
- The Life and Career of General George Meade
- De: Charles River Editors
- Narrado por: Scott Clem
Inaccurate, full of quotes by Grant cronies
Revisado: 09-26-20
There are no good audiobooks on Meade and until there are, the only book that comes close to representing Meade’s true contributions in the war is Isaac Rusling Pennypacker’s, Great Commanders General Meade, 1901. There is money in the continuing promotion of Grant, Sherman, Sheridan, Lee, Forrest, and Jackson but this is capitalism and 19th century politics at work not history. The tedious comments on his looks and temper are so incredibly shallow and misrepresentative of this great general’s worth that this book isn’t worth it even for free.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña
-
Grant
- A Biography
- De: William McFeely
- Narrado por: Jeff Riggenbach
- Duración: 27 h y 9 m
- Versión completa
-
General
-
Narración:
-
Historia
Having once said “a military life had no charms to me,” U.S. Grant entered West Point to get through the course, secure a detail for a few years as assistant professor of mathematics at the Academy, and afterwards obtain a permanent position as professor at some respectable college. But the course his life took was quite different. Little did he ever dream that he would serve with distinction in the Mexican War, lead the Union to victory in the Civil War, and struggle through eight years as President of the United States.
-
-
A Disappointing Book
- De Eric en 06-29-15
- Grant
- A Biography
- De: William McFeely
- Narrado por: Jeff Riggenbach
More balanced than later works
Revisado: 09-26-20
Early in my studies, having read Bruce Catton and Shelby Foote, I was put off by McFeely’s biography and set it aside reading Jean Edward Smith instead. Now having read Carswell McClellan and many other primary source books disputing Grant’s Memoirs, I find it a much more accurate narrative than later books that have glossed over his failings and tend to create an over the top mythical Grant. Although author is criticized for his speculations on Grant’s psychological states it seems now an interesting and fair enough appraisal. I enjoyed audiobook format very much.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña
-
Meade and Lee After Gettysburg: The Forgotten Final Stage of the Gettysburg Campaign, from Falling Waters to Culpeper Court House, July 14-31, 1863
- De: Jeffrey Wm Hunt
- Narrado por: Colonel Ralph Henning
- Duración: 8 h y 18 m
- Versión completa
-
General
-
Narración:
-
Historia
The Gettysburg Campaign did not end at the banks of the Potomac on July 14, but two weeks later, deep in central Virginia along the line of the Rappahannock. Once Robert E. Lee’s Army of Northern Virginia slipped across the swollen Potomac back to Virginia, the Lincoln administration pressed George Meade to cross quickly in pursuit - and he did. Rather than follow in Lee’s wake, however, Meade moved south on the east side of the Blue Ridge Mountains in a cat-and-mouse game to outthink his enemy and capture the strategic gaps penetrating the high, wooded terrain.
-
-
Mispronunciations Abound
- De Judy Morley en 07-30-24
A Texan writes about Meade
Revisado: 12-12-19
This is a standard dismissal of George Gordon Meade’s generalship that ruins an otherwise fine telling of the movements and challenges of pursuing an army through mountain passes. Like a Monday night quarter back he sees only the possibilities of some grand strategic offensive that he concludes Meade was incapable of navigating. Easy to contend since Lee did get away but so simplistic a mindset and poorly supported by the facts that it’s distracting.
The premise that Meade was ineffective rests first on the fact that he did not bring Lee to battle at Williamsport. He thanks Kent Masterson Brown in his acknowledgments but one wonders if he read his book. The author concludes: “A potential (and it is important to stress that word) opportunity to destroy Lee at Williamsport had been squandered, and the chance to potentially cut off and wreck a portion of his army in the Valley was also missed. An even greater and more realistic chance to beat the Rebels to the Rappahannock or Rapidan was lost as well.”
The author simply ignores recent scholarship by both Kent Masterson Brown (read his description of entrenchments pg. 310-312) and Eric Wittenberg on the pursuit after Gettysburg. Starting with the erroneous and tired premise that Meade “squandered” an opportunity to defeat Lee at Williamsport is a poor place to start the narrative and he keep using this to bolster his argument that Meade was a cautious, General who “took counsel of his fears” and had no strategic vision. I was very disappointed with the author’s intrusive assessment of a general in command of his army for just three days, who then fought and won a bloody victory over the Civil War’s most audacious and aggressive general that even with Grant at the helm was not defeated until eighteen months later. There is very little military appreciation for the comparative ease of escaping in general. One could ask why Grant and Sherman did not pursue the Confederates immediately after Shiloh having been reinforced by Buell or for that matter, why stop pursuing Bragg after Chattanooga.
Let the reader come to our own conclusions based on the facts presented, that is all I’m asking. I respectfully recognize the author’s research and skill of presentation but I submit his assessments were too heavy handed.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña

-
The Half Has Never Been Told
- Slavery and the Making of American Capitalism
- De: Edward E. Baptist
- Narrado por: Ron Butler
- Duración: 19 h y 47 m
- Versión completa
-
General
-
Narración:
-
Historia
In The Half Has Never Been Told, historian Edward E. Baptist reveals the alarming extent to which slavery shaped our country politically, morally, and most of all, economically. Until the Civil War, our chief form of innovation was slavery. Through forced migration and torture, slave owners extracted continual increases in efficiency from their slaves, giving the country a virtual monopoly on the production of cotton, a key raw material of the Industrial Revolution.
-
-
A Book that Must Be Read
- De William en 09-29-15
- The Half Has Never Been Told
- Slavery and the Making of American Capitalism
- De: Edward E. Baptist
- Narrado por: Ron Butler
An original and mind blowing work
Revisado: 03-09-19
This book is so original in its organization and powerful in its message that some will be confused and uncomfortable. I read the book before listening to this incredible narration and marveled at the control in his voice, the cadence that so perfectly captures the rhythm of industrialized slavery. Should be required reading for all.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña

-
Gettysburg
- De: Stephen Sears
- Narrado por: Ed Sala
- Duración: 23 h y 4 m
- Versión completa
-
General
-
Narración:
-
Historia
Best-selling author and acclaimed Civil War expert Stephen W. Sears, hailed by The New York Times Book Review as “arguably the preeminent living historian of the war’s eastern theater,” crafts what will stand the test of time as the definitive history of the greatest battle ever fought on American soil. Drawing on years of research, Sears focuses on the big picture, capturing the entire essence of the momentous three day struggle while offering fresh insights that will surprise even the best versed Civil War buffs.
-
-
The Storyteller's Craft and the Scholar's Care
- De John en 02-18-17
- Gettysburg
- De: Stephen Sears
- Narrado por: Ed Sala
My second read and enjoyed it immensely
Revisado: 10-26-18
I don’t agree with absolutely everything Sears has written about the great battle but I think he captures the essence and it would be nit picking to dissect such a wonderful book and find fault. He gives a very fair characterization of both Lee and Meade. His treatment of the 11th Corp is the standard viewpoint and I would urge readers to read James Pula’s two volume books on the 11th Corp for balance. Perhaps people emphasize Gettysburg too much but I don’t think so. It is a perfectly beautiful battlefield to walk and all the elements of battle seem to engage one there, the enormity of it, the carnage, the complexity of the three day struggle. For me Gettysburg represents that ultimate contest that was the Civil War. The audiobook is a great way to review information a second time around.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña
-
Gettysburg: The Last Invasion
- De: Allen C. Guelzo
- Narrado por: Robertson Dean
- Duración: 22 h y 33 m
- Versión completa
-
General
-
Narración:
-
Historia
From the acclaimed Civil War historian, a brilliant new history–the most intimate and richly readable account we have had–of the climactic three-day battle of Gettysburg (July 1–3, 1863), which draws the reader into the heat, smoke, and grime of Gettysburg alongside the ordinary soldier, and depicts the combination of personalities and circumstances that produced the greatest battle of the Civil War, and one of the greatest in human history.
-
-
A Fresh Look at a Famous Battle
- De W. F. Rucker en 07-03-13
- Gettysburg: The Last Invasion
- De: Allen C. Guelzo
- Narrado por: Robertson Dean
Author has a vendetta against Meade
Revisado: 10-20-18
The author makes no pretense of presenting an unbiased account of the battle or letting reader come to their own conclusions about the key players in the battle. It is very readable for anyone without a Civil War background but for anyone remotely familiar with the facts this psycho babble will feel like someone dragging their nails across a black board. Torture!!!! I hated this book. The narrator sounds just like the author.
Se ha producido un error. Vuelve a intentarlo dentro de unos minutos.
Has calificado esta reseña.
Reportaste esta reseña