Amazon Customer

Good

Revisado: 04-08-24

Lord of drama and excitement, truly loved this book!!

I recommend it if you would like to see what else would unfold in this new series. It has the perspective of a Riverclan cat, and Riverclan never gets enough love.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Good. I do give spoilers in this review.

Revisado: 05-21-23

It’s a great book. I do hate the fact Skykit tried to drown Leopardkit. Leopardkit may have been a bit spoiled but the clan did feel bad for her being motherless. Anyways, Leopardpaw/fur/star was not always the brightest. She was determined to prove herself strong and with that strength, came hardheadedness. She was so hardheaded that she got her own deputy killed and didn’t realize until to late TigerClaw/star was an evil cat. If Skykit hadn’t gotten annoyed and jealous with Leopardkit for giving her (Skykits) hiding place away, Leopardkit/paw wouldn’t have been terrified of water. SkyPaw was a rude cat but once they reached warrior-hood, Skyheart and Leopardfur did become good friends again. I just wish Skykit/paw wasn’t so rude to Leopardkit/paw just because LeopardKit gave Skykits hiding place away to SedgeKit. Revenge isn’t always the best thing, especially if it’s just a game like hide ‘n seek. Overall, this was a great book and I would recommend it to many other people. Although I LOVE YellowFang’s secret and BlueStar’s Prophecy (mainly because they don’t make the chapters about the cats life so quick). LeopardStar’s Honor just flew through her kit-hood, apprentice-hood, and warrior-hood right to her being deputy than instantly her becoming leader. Anyways, I do love this book, and obviously will give it a ♾️/10 because it is a warrior cat book.

Ty for your hard work Erins!

Bye!

P.s. Warrior cats Progress: 80+ books, 1000+ characters, and much much more. They even have pillows, water bottles, and stickers!!

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

I love this book :)

Revisado: 05-03-23

This book, overall, is amazing. I love how Crowfeather grows close to his former Windclan mate, Nightcloud, and his Windclan son, Breezepelt. I love every second of the book, and it’s a book I would listen to for life. Personally, WindClan is my favorite clan.

Anyways, this is kinda a shorter review, there’s not much I can put into words about how amazing this book it.

May Starclan light the paths of you all!

Sincerely, FernCloud (Star)

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Eh.. A bit dramatic and..

Revisado: 04-27-23

It’s okay I guess.. not really my favorite. SquirrelFlight is isn’t my favorite character. She was kinda “I’m coming and you can’t do anything” and very needy and whiney. She was almost always wanting stuff for herself and although she cared for her clan, she just wasn’t really thinking of how others might feel. And in the newest books, she just is so… rude. She is so harsh and mean to Flamepaw/Shade(shadow)heart (don’t remember his name) and didn’t understand how he felt being connected to FireStar. I feel, ever since ThunderClan was a better clan when Bluestar was young and when ThunderClan was first born. But now it’s just… no.


Now. I have to go. Patrols. May StarClan light the paths of all!

Sincerely, SageBriar / Star WC deputy (leader)

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

I recommend reading this.

Revisado: 04-27-23

Let me say a few things, these books great, a lot of excitement. The reader is amazing. I honestly love the performance but the story is.. in my opinion isn’t so great.. I am a person who normally handles gore pretty well but when I listened to these books, I just could barely handle it. It was awful, some of the deaths in these books. It’s probably the goriest book I’ve listened to/read. For those who aren’t able to handle gore, DON’T GET THESE BOOKS!! I know it doesn’t show the pictures, but it gives you a good enough explanation to give you a picture in your mind of the scene. So, if you can handle gore and horrible deaths.. get this.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

READ THIS

Revisado: 04-27-23

Let me say a few things, these books great, a lot of excitement. The reader is amazing. I honestly love the performance but the story is.. in my opinion isn’t so great.. I am a person who normally handles gore pretty well but when I listened to these books, I just could barely handle it. It was awful, some of the deaths in these books. It’s probably the goriest book I’ve listened to/read. For those who aren’t able to handle gore, DON’T GET THESE BOOKS!! I know it doesn’t show the pictures, but it gives you a good enough explanation to give you a picture in your mind of the scene. So, if you can handle gore and horrible deaths.. get this.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Read this before getting the book

Revisado: 04-27-23

Let me say a few things, these books great, a lot of excitement. The reader is amazing. I honestly love the performance but the story is.. in my opinion isn’t so great.. I am a person who normally handles gore pretty well but when I listened to these books, I just could barely handle it. It was awful, some of the deaths in these books. It’s probably the goriest book I’ve listened to/read. For those who aren’t able to handle gore, DON’T GET THESE BOOKS!! I know it doesn’t show the pictures, but it gives you a good enough explanation to give you a picture in your mind of the scene. So, if you can handle gore and horrible deaths.. get this.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

It’s good but..

Revisado: 04-27-23

So Onestars parents are Wrenflight and Stagleap, but in Tallstars revenge, the two are littermates (siblings) and Wrenflight already had Shrewfoots kits. It’s like Graystripes parent whom are siblings but became mates.

I’m making my own books and keep notes on who’s mates and siblings.. and personally I think the Erin’s should do something like that so that siblings don’t become mates in thre future of warriors.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

Honestly BlueStar deserves better

Revisado: 04-17-23

It’s a great book, as always. I could not get enough of the Erin Hunter books. One thing I hate about this book in particular is that BlueStar lost everyone she loved, although her two kits MistyStar and StoneFur still live on, they are in a different clan. It’s honestly hard to imagine the grief BlueStar suffered. If she had not lost her kin, she may not have had to fear about the lie that she had about 2-4 lives left at the end of the book. I just wish BlueStar didn’t suffer so much. Out of all the books, I think BlueStar sacrificed the most and suffered the most. Anyways, this is my opinion, so you may disagree, you may agree.

Anyways, may we, StarClan, light your paths!

-BriarGorse, Former WindClan Deputy (“Death: Bitten in throat, and it got infected”)




[it’s just my warrior cat! </3)

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

My opinion and mine alone (unless u agree :)) GO DOWN FOR ENGLISH

Revisado: 04-10-23

Español:

Así que antes de empezar con mis pensamientos sobre este libro, quiero que todos sepan que esta es mi opinión personal y que nadie tiene que estar de acuerdo o en desacuerdo.

¡Oh! Y antes de que empieces a leer mi reseña, ¡¡¡ADVERTENCIA DE SPOILERS LIGEROS!!! Lee bajo tu propio riesgo...

Mi reseña sobre el libro:

Cuando se lanzó por primera vez, lo conseguí y estaba súper emocionado. Al principio, fue muy emocionante, pero a medida que avanzaba en el libro, no podía dejar de escucharlo. Lo terminé el día que salió. Cuando el aprendiz, FrostPaw, finalmente le dijo a su "amigo" SplashTail, él la "ayuó". Cuando FrostPaw fue a Windclan para hablar con el aprendiz de medicina, fue atacada por un gato y posiblemente asesinada. Siento que SplashTail la mató... pero supongo que yo mismo, ya que él es su amigo, y él quiere que sea un gato medicinal para ayudar a Riverclan, así que, a menos que algún gato estuviera espiando, o de alguna manera supiera lo que estaba planeando esa noche, pensaré que es SplashTail quien ha estado haciendo todos los asesinatos. Estoy muy emocionado por el próximo libro.

Atentamente, CheckeredTail (Windclans med.)

English:

So before I start about my thoughts of this book, I want everyone to know that this is my personal opinion and no one has to agree or disagree.

Oh! And before you start reading my review, SLIGHT SPOILERS WARNING!!! Read at your own risk…











My review about the book:

When it was first released, I got it, and was super excited. At first, it was very exciting, but as it got further into the book, I couldn’t stop listening to it. I finished it the day it came out. When the apprentice, FrostPaw finally told her “friend” SplashTail, he “helped” her. When FrostPaw went to Windclan to talk to the medicine apprentice, she was attacked by a cat, and possibly murdered. I feel SplashTail killed her.. but I second guess myself since he is her friend, and he wants her to be a medicine cat to help Riverclan, so, unless some cat was spying, or somehow knew what she was planning that night, I will think it’s SplashTail who has been doing all the murders. I am so excited for the next book.


Sincerely, CheckeredTail (Windclans med.)

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña

esto le resultó útil a 1 persona