Phoebe Martin

DISAPPOINTING

Revisado: 07-15-17

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

Not really, the story starts out with the main character believing that Grady was at fault for killing her mother - then it takes you on a long journey to change her mind and make you believe that someone else was at fault and he was in prison unjustly. All of this - just to find out he was the killer. What a waste.

I really liked the story up until the end - I liked how it flipped back and fourth between the present and the past.

The ending was just so disappointing because I envisioned Janie's closed minded perception that Grady killed her mother and that now they could have a father / daughter relationship, and since he really was the killer it made other things earlier not really make any sense. Also, since Bridget found the note on accident - why was the Leroy guy following her like he did back to her place if he wasn't the killer? Makes NO sense now. The ending would have made more sense if he was not the killer. Also, the book never lined out what Leroy was going to do with the note he found, or who the note was really for. Was it an accident that it went down that way or was that the way Grady meant for it to happen? No one knows....

If you’ve listened to books by Anne McAneny before, how does this one compare?

This is my first book by Anne McAneny

Have you listened to any of Emily Sutton-Smith’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

I have no idea - I think this is my first audio by Emily Sutton-Smith

Any additional comments?

Meh.

Has calificado esta reseña.

Reportaste esta reseña